A gravity flush toilet uses gravity rather than a powered macerator to move waste into an RV’s holding tank, making fit, bowl design, and flush control the key buying differences. My best overall pick is the Dometic Model 410, which pairs a porcelain bowl with an 18-inch chair-height design and a soft-close seat. The Dometic Model 420 stands out for buyers who want an elongated porcelain bowl, while the Dometic Model 400 offers a simpler plastic-bowl alternative. The main tradeoffs are porcelain versus lighter plastic, compact versus residential-height seating, and foot-pedal convenience versus other flush controls. Read on for the full breakdown and help matching a toilet to your RV’s space and plumbing.
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Dometic Model 410 leads as an all-around choice because it combines a porcelain bowl, chair-height seating, and a soft-close seat without prioritizing only one feature.
- Porcelain and plastic serve different RV needs: the Dometic 410, 420, and SEAFLO porcelain options focus on a more residential bowl feel, while plastic models can suit buyers prioritizing a lighter, simpler unit.
- Seat height varies enough to affect comfort and clearance. The listed options range from standard high-profile designs to residential-height models and a 20-inch HeyJiaYu, so buyers should check both user comfort and available vertical space.
- Elongated bowls are a targeted upgrade, not an automatic win. The Dometic 420 and several SEAFLO options offer that shape, but a round bowl may fit better in a tighter bathroom.
- Foot pedals and sprayer attachments change the routine, not the basic flush principle. They can suit different cleaning and control preferences, but buyers still need to verify their RV’s mounting and water connections.
| gravity flush toilet | Model | Dimensions | Material |
|---|---|---|---|
| MuRealy High-Profile RV Toilet | 2025 | — | Plastic |
| Clirass 3702T Gravity-Flush RV | 3702T | 19.1 in D x 15.6 in W x 19.9 in H | Plastic |
| SEAFLO RV Toilet with Sprayer | SFRTPH-01-02 | 17.8 x 15.3 x 18.4 inches | Lightweight durable plastic |
| Dometic Model 410 Complete RV | 410 | 17.63 x 15 x 19.63 inches (D x W x H) | — |
| Dometic Model 400 Essential RV | 400 Essential | — | — |
| VINGLI RV Toilet with Foot Ped | RVT458 | 19.1 × 15.55 × 34.45 inches | HDPE and PP plastic |
| Kohree RV Toilet with 18.5-Inc | KR3141 | 17.1 × 15 × 18.5 inches (D × W × H) | Polypropylene (PP) |
| SEAFLO Bone RV Toilet | SFRTPH-02-01 | 17.8 × 15.3 × 18.4 inches | — |
| SEAFLO Porcelain RV Toilet wit | SFRTCH-02-02 | 20.51 × 14.17 × 19 inches | — |
| Dometic Model 420 Platinum RV | 420 Platinum | 19 × 15 × 19.63 inches (D × W × H) | — |
| Thetford Aqua-Magic VI High-Pr | 31835 | 20.63 × 18.13 × 15.5 inches (D × W × H) | Polypropylene |
| HeyJiaYu 20-Inch High-Profile | HJY-22GFT001 | 19.12 × 15.56 × 20.06 inches (D × W × H) | HDPE |
| Shineforu Gravity Flush RV Toi | Rv-1001 | 19.09 × 15.55 × 19.88 inches (D × W × H) | ABS plastic |
| SEAFLO RV Toilet with Foot Ped | SFRTPH-01-01 | 17.8 × 15.3 × 18.4 inches | Lightweight durable plastic |
| SEAFLO Porcelain RV Toilet wit | SFRTCH-02-01 | 20.51 × 14.17 × 19 inches | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
MuRealy High-Profile RV Toilet with Gravity Flush
The MuRealy High-Profile suits RV owners who want straightforward gravity flushing with hands-free controls. Its two-position foot pedal separates filling from flushing, giving you control over water use without reaching for a lever. The T-type outlet is intended to rinse the bowl, while the included floor-mounting components simplify the parts list for installation. Compared with the Clirass 3702T, which adds a triple-jet system and adjustable water level, the MuRealy has a simpler stated flush design and fewer water-control details. Its plastic construction keeps the format suited to RV use, but buyers who prefer the solid feel of porcelain should look at the Dometic Model 410 instead. Check the pedal orientation against your layout before buying, since its position may feel unexpected from some viewing angles.
Pros:- Two-position pedal allows hands-free filling and flushing
- T-type outlet is designed to rinse the bowl
- Floor-mounting installation components are included
- Anti-noise seat and lid help limit closing sounds
Cons:- Plastic bowl and seat feel less substantial than porcelain alternatives such as the Dometic Model 410
- Pedal position may feel unintuitive depending on the installation and viewing orientation
Best for: RV and travel-trailer owners who want a high-profile plastic toilet with hands-free pedal control and included floor-mounting components.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a porcelain bowl, or RV owners who need a clearly specified water-saving adjustment or a multi-jet flush system.
- Brand:MuRealy
- Model:2025
- Flush type:Gravity flush
- Flush control:Two-position foot pedal
- Material:Plastic
- Installation:Floor mounted
- Weight:6.71 kg
- Intended use:RVs, campers, and travel trailers
Our verdict“Choose the MuRealy if you want a high-profile RV toilet with simple, hands-free pedal operation and can accept plastic construction.”
Clirass 3702T Gravity-Flush RV Toilet with Slow-Close Seat
The Clirass 3702T is the clearest choice here for buyers who want more control over the flush: it pairs a triple-jet gravity system with an adjustable water level. That combination is designed to improve bowl coverage while letting owners tune water use, a more specified approach than the MuRealy’s T-type outlet. Its foot pedal keeps operation hands-free, and the slow-close seat helps avoid a sharp lid slam in a compact RV. At 18 inches high, it offers standard-height seating, but its stated dimensions and round bowl may not suit every bathroom layout. Installation also has a specific catch: the bottom edge requires sealing with glass glue. Compared with the Dometic Model 400 Essential, the Clirass emphasizes adjustable flushing rather than a compact rear profile and a documented rough-in fit.
Pros:- Triple-jet gravity flush is designed for broad bowl cleaning
- Adjustable water level gives owners control over water use
- Foot-pedal operation keeps flushing hands-free
- Slow-close seat reduces lid noise
Cons:- Installation requires sealing the bottom edge with glass glue
- Plastic bowl and seat lack the more substantial feel of porcelain models
- Round bowl may be less appealing to buyers seeking an elongated seat
Best for: RV, trailer, and camper owners who want hands-free operation plus an adjustable water level for managing flush volume.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a simple install without applying a bottom-edge seal, or those who need a porcelain bowl or elongated seat.
- Model:3702T
- Flush type:Gravity flush with triple-jet system
- Operation:Foot pedal
- Water level:Adjustable
- Height:18 inches
- Dimensions:19.1 in D x 15.6 in W x 19.9 in H
- Material:Plastic
- Installation:Floor mounted
Our verdict“Pick the Clirass 3702T if adjustable flush-water control matters more to you than a simpler installation or porcelain construction.”
SEAFLO RV Toilet with Sprayer Attachment, Soft-Close Seat, White
The SEAFLO SFRTPH-01-02 stands apart by including a handheld sprayer and mounting bracket, a useful addition for buyers who want a separate rinse tool alongside gravity flushing. Its 18.4-inch residential-height design and elongated, soft-close seat lean toward a more home-like fit than the round-bowl Clirass 3702T. Adjustable water flow gives the foot-pedal gravity flush some flexibility, and the listed four-year warranty provides a defined coverage period. The tradeoff is practical: the floor flange is not included, so buyers may need to source a compatible part before installation. Its lightweight plastic construction also differs from the porcelain Dometic Model 410, which is the better match for someone prioritizing a ceramic bowl over lower weight and added sprayer utility.
Pros:- Handheld sprayer and mounting bracket are included
- 18.4-inch height and elongated seat offer a residential-style fit
- Soft-close seat reduces closing noise
- Four-year warranty is specified
Cons:- Floor flange is not included
- Plastic construction may feel less substantial than the Dometic Model 410’s porcelain bowl
- Elongated shape may be a poorer fit in tight bathroom layouts
Best for: RV and marine owners who want residential-height elongated seating, a handheld sprayer, and a stated four-year warranty.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a toilet supplied with a floor flange, or those who prefer the feel and cleanability of a porcelain bowl.
- Model:SFRTPH-01-02
- Flush system:Gravity flush with adjustable water flow
- Operation:Foot pedal
- Height:18.4 inches (47 cm)
- Dimensions:17.8 x 15.3 x 18.4 inches
- Seat:Soft-close, elongated
- Material:Lightweight durable plastic
- Warranty:4 years
Our verdict“Choose this SEAFLO when the included sprayer and elongated residential-height seat matter more than having the flange supplied or a porcelain bowl.”
Dometic Model 410 Complete RV Toilet, Round Porcelain Bowl, 18-Inch Chair Height, Gravity Flush, Soft-Close Seat, White
The Dometic Model 410 is the strongest fit for buyers who want a porcelain bowl in an RV-ready gravity toilet. Its rimless flush is designed to rinse the bowl, while the dual-action foot pedal lets the user manage flushing and water flow. The 18-inch chair-height seat and soft-close lid add everyday comfort, and the 2-bolt universal mount can make it a practical replacement candidate when the existing floor setup is compatible. Compared with the lighter plastic Dometic Model 400 Essential, the 410 offers porcelain and a replaceable seal, but weighs 27 pounds rather than 16. That extra weight and the need to confirm RV plumbing and mounting compatibility make it less suitable for weight-conscious builds or buyers seeking a quick, universal swap.
Pros:- Porcelain bowl offers a more substantial, easy-to-clean surface than plastic models
- Rimless gravity flush is designed to rinse the bowl
- 18-inch chair-height seat and soft-close lid support comfortable, quieter use
- 2-bolt universal mount and replaceable seal support replacement and maintenance
Cons:- At 27 pounds, it is heavier than the plastic Dometic Model 400 Essential
- Floor mounting and RV plumbing must be compatible
- Round bowl may not suit buyers who prefer an elongated seat
Best for: RV owners replacing a compatible 2-bolt toilet who prefer a porcelain bowl, chair-height seating, and serviceable flush components.
Not ideal for: Weight-conscious RV owners, or anyone whose floor mount and plumbing do not match the toilet’s 2-bolt installation.
- Brand:Dometic
- Model:410
- Flush type:Gravity flush
- Bowl material:Porcelain
- Seat height:18 inches
- Mounting:Floor-mounted, 2-bolt
- Dimensions:17.63 x 15 x 19.63 inches (D x W x H)
- Weight:27 pounds
Our verdict“Choose the Dometic Model 410 if porcelain and maintenance-friendly features outweigh added weight and the need to verify your RV’s mounting fit.”
Dometic Model 400 Essential RV Toilet, Round Plastic Bowl, 18-Inch Chair Height, Soft-Close Seat, White
The Dometic Model 400 Essential prioritizes a manageable replacement fit over the porcelain feel of the Model 410. At 16 pounds, it is 11 pounds lighter than that porcelain alternative, and its compact rear profile is intended for tighter RV layouts. The 2-bolt mount is designed for standard rough-ins of 7.625 inches or greater, giving buyers a concrete measurement to check before ordering. Its spray flush system and soft-close seat cover the practical basics, while the position-lock hinge is designed to aid cleaning. The tradeoff is a plastic bowl and seat, which feel less substantial than the 410’s porcelain construction. Unlike the Clirass 3702T, the Model 400 does not list an adjustable water level, so it is a better match for fit and lower weight than for flush customization.
Pros:- 16-pound construction is lighter than the Dometic Model 410
- Compact rear profile can help with tighter RV bathroom layouts
- 2-bolt mount is specified for rough-ins of 7.625 inches or greater
- Soft-close seat and position-lock hinge support quieter use and cleaning
Cons:- Plastic bowl and seat feel less substantial than the Dometic Model 410’s porcelain
- Round bowl may not suit buyers who prefer an elongated seat
- Requires a compatible floor-mounted 2-bolt rough-in
Best for: RV owners replacing a toilet in a tighter layout who want a lighter plastic model and can confirm a compatible 2-bolt rough-in.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a porcelain bowl, an elongated seat, or adjustable flush-water settings.
- Brand:Dometic
- Model:400 Essential
- Type:Gravity flush RV toilet
- Bowl material:Plastic
- Seat height:18 inches
- Mounting:Floor mounted, 2-bolt
- Compatible rough-in:7.625 inches or greater
- Weight:16 pounds
Our verdict“Pick the Model 400 Essential for a lighter, compact replacement when your rough-in matches and plastic construction is acceptable.”
VINGLI RV Toilet with Foot Pedal Gravity Flush
At 15 pounds, the VINGLI is the lightest clearly specified option in this group, making it a sensible fit when keeping RV weight down matters. Its dual-function foot pedal adds water and triggers the gravity flush, while the deep bowl is intended to limit splash-back. The 18.7-inch seat height is close to residential height, and the soft-close seat keeps lid noise down in a compact living space. Compared with the porcelain-bowl Dometic Model 420 Platinum, VINGLI is easier to lift and handle but gives up the harder, more substantial bowl surface. The HDPE and PP construction also feels less premium than porcelain. A hand sprayer appears in the product title, but the supplied details do not confirm one is included, so I would not choose it on that assumption.
Pros:- Lightweight 15-pound construction suits weight-conscious RV setups.
- Dual-function pedal adds water and activates the gravity flush.
- Deep bowl is designed to reduce splash-back.
- Soft-close seat helps limit lid noise.
Cons:- HDPE and PP body and plastic seat may feel less substantial than porcelain options.
- Hand sprayer inclusion is not confirmed in the supplied product details.
Best for: RV owners prioritizing low toilet weight, a foot-operated gravity flush, and a near-residential seat height.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a porcelain bowl or need confirmed sprayer accessories, since its body is plastic and the sprayer is not detailed.
- Model:RVT458
- Flush type:Gravity flush
- Flush control:Dual-function foot pedal
- Material:HDPE and PP plastic
- Seat height:18.7 inches
- Dimensions:19.1 × 15.55 × 34.45 inches
- Weight:15 pounds
- Seat:Plastic, soft-close
Our verdict“Choose the VINGLI if low weight and pedal operation matter more than a porcelain bowl or a confirmed sprayer.”
Kohree RV Toilet with 18.5-Inch Residential Height and Soft-Close Seat
The Kohree is the most installation-ready choice here: its package includes a floor flange, seal, screws, and sprayer attachment, reducing the need to source several fitment parts separately. Its 18.5-inch seat and deep anti-stick bowl aim for familiar comfort, while the dual-action pedal runs a water-saving gravity flush with a triple-jet rinse. That rinse setup gives it a more feature-rich flushing description than the VINGLI, whose supplied details mention pedal operation but not a rinse pattern. The tradeoff is that Kohree still uses polypropylene for the body, rather than the porcelain bowl found on the Dometic Model 420 Platinum. It is also limited to a compatible floor-mounted RV connection, so included hardware does not make it a universal fit.
Pros:- Package includes a floor flange, toilet seals, screws, and sprayer attachment.
- Dual-action pedal operates a gravity flush with triple-jet rinse.
- 18.5-inch seat height and deep bowl suit buyers seeking residential-style use.
- Soft-close seat and cover reduce slamming noise.
Cons:- Polypropylene body and seat lack the hard bowl surface of porcelain models.
- Requires a compatible floor-mounted RV toilet connection.
Best for: RV owners replacing a floor-mounted toilet who want the flange, seals, fasteners, and sprayer attachment bundled together.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a porcelain bowl or those whose RV lacks a compatible floor-mounted, two-bolt connection.
- Model:KR3141
- Flush:Gravity flush with triple-jet rinse
- Operation:Dual-action foot pedal
- Seat height:18.5 inches
- Dimensions:17.1 × 15 × 18.5 inches (D × W × H)
- Material:Polypropylene (PP)
- Mounting:Floor-mounted, 2-bolt mount
- Warranty:2 years
- Included components:Floor flange, toilet, screws, sprayer attachment, toilet seals
Our verdict“Pick the Kohree when bundled installation parts and a triple-jet pedal flush outweigh the appeal of porcelain construction.”
SEAFLO Bone RV Toilet, Residential Height, Gravity Flush Foot Pedal, Soft-Close Seat, Parchment
The SEAFLO Bone stands apart through its parchment finish, a useful match for RV interiors where bright white fixtures look out of place. Its 18.4-inch height and oversized elongated bowl favor comfort over the compact footprint of the Dometic Model 420 Platinum. A foot pedal controls the gravity flush, and the soft-close seat and lid help keep movement quiet. The lightweight plastic construction suits mobile use, but it will not provide the smooth, hard bowl surface of the Dometic’s porcelain. The clearest ownership drawback is fitment: the floor flange is sold separately, unlike the Kohree package, which includes a flange and seals. The four-year limited warranty and listed IAPMO standards add useful documentation, but buyers still need to confirm the separate flange suits their installation.
Pros:- Parchment finish can coordinate with warmer RV interiors.
- Oversized elongated bowl and 18.4-inch height prioritize seated comfort.
- Lightweight construction suits RV use.
- Includes a four-year limited warranty.
Cons:- Floor flange must be purchased separately.
- Plastic bowl does not offer the porcelain surface of the Dometic Model 420 Platinum.
Best for: RV owners with parchment or warm-toned interiors who prefer an elongated bowl and residential-height seating.
Not ideal for: Buyers wanting a ready-to-mount package or porcelain bowl, since the flange is separate and the construction is plastic.
- Model:SFRTPH-02-01
- Color:Bone Parchment
- Flush system:Gravity flush, foot pedal operation
- Height:18.4 inches
- Dimensions:17.8 × 15.3 × 18.4 inches
- Bowl:Oversized elongated design
- Construction:Lightweight durable plastic
- Warranty:4-year limited warranty
- Floor flange:Sold separately
Our verdict“Choose this SEAFLO for a parchment finish and roomy elongated bowl if you are prepared to source a compatible flange separately.”
SEAFLO Porcelain RV Toilet with Sprayer Attachment, Elongated Bowl, 19-Inch Height
This SEAFLO pairs an elongated porcelain bowl with a plastic base, a combination aimed at buyers who want a smooth, easy-to-clean bowl without an all-porcelain toilet’s construction. The 19-inch height is the tallest specified among these five, and the foot pedal offers adjustable water flow during the gravity flush. A handheld sprayer and wall mount come included, giving it a clear cleanup advantage over the VINGLI, whose sprayer listing is not confirmed in the supplied details. The compromise is in the mixed-material build: the base may feel less substantial than the porcelain bowl, and this unit is designed for RV and motorhome systems rather than household plumbing. Its four-year limited warranty adds coverage, but buyers should check their RV connection and available space against the listed dimensions before choosing it.
Pros:- Porcelain bowl provides a smooth, non-porous surface for cleaning.
- Foot pedal allows hands-free flushing with adjustable water flow.
- Handheld sprayer and wall mount are included.
- Four-year limited warranty.
Cons:- Plastic base may feel less substantial than an all-porcelain toilet.
- Designed for RV and motorhome toilet systems, not general household installation.
Best for: RV owners who want a porcelain bowl, adjustable pedal-controlled flushing, and an included handheld sprayer for cleanup.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking an all-porcelain build or a toilet for standard household plumbing rather than an RV system.
- Model:SFRTCH-02-02
- Flush system:Gravity flush with adjustable water flow
- Operation:Foot pedal
- Height:19 inches
- Dimensions:20.51 × 14.17 × 19 inches
- Bowl:Elongated porcelain
- Base:Lightweight durable plastic
- Included:Handheld sprayer attachment with wall mount
- Warranty:4-year limited warranty
Our verdict“Choose this SEAFLO if bowl cleanability and a bundled sprayer matter more than an all-porcelain construction.”
Dometic Model 420 Platinum RV Toilet with Elongated Porcelain Bowl
The Dometic Model 420 Platinum earns its place for buyers working around a constrained RV layout: its compact rear profile and universal two-bolt mount are designed for standard rough-ins measuring at least 7.625 inches. The scratch-resistant porcelain bowl offers a more substantial, easier-to-clean surface than the plastic bowls on the VINGLI and Kohree. Its soft-close seat uses a position-lock hinge that can help keep the seat in place during use. That porcelain comes with a weight penalty: at 31 pounds, it is much heavier than the 15-pound VINGLI, so it is less appealing when minimizing installed weight is a priority. The seat itself is plastic, and the rough-in requirement is a firm fitment limit; measure the existing connection before selecting it.
Pros:- Scratch-resistant porcelain bowl is easier to clean than plastic bowl surfaces.
- Compact rear profile suits tighter installation spaces.
- Universal two-bolt mount fits standard RV rough-ins of 7.625 inches or greater.
- Soft-close seat has an easy-clean, position-lock hinge.
Cons:- At 31 pounds, it is substantially heavier than the VINGLI.
- Requires a rough-in of at least 7.625 inches.
- Seat is plastic rather than porcelain.
Best for: RV owners replacing a toilet in a tighter rear-clearance layout who want a porcelain bowl and a standard two-bolt mount.
Not ideal for: Weight-conscious RV owners or anyone with a rough-in under 7.625 inches or a preference for an all-porcelain seat and bowl.
- Model:420 Platinum
- Model number:9610008281
- Flush type:Gravity flush
- Bowl material:Porcelain
- Mount:Floor-mounted, universal 2-bolt
- Minimum rough-in:7.625 inches
- Dimensions:19 × 15 × 19.63 inches (D × W × H)
- Weight:31 pounds
- Seat material:Plastic
Our verdict“Pick the Dometic Model 420 Platinum when rear clearance and a porcelain bowl matter more than minimizing toilet weight.”
Thetford Aqua-Magic VI High-Profile RV Toilet, White
The Aqua-Magic VI suits RV owners who need a floor-mounted gravity-flush toilet that can sit close to the wall without giving up a taller seat. Its 18-inch seating height is lower than the HeyJiaYu’s 20-inch height, which may feel more manageable for people who find extra-tall toilets awkward. The foot pedal also gives two levels of control: press partway to add water, then fully to flush. A residential-size SloClose seat adds a more familiar feel than a basic plastic-seat setup. The tradeoff is that this model’s description does not specify bowl coverage or water-use adjustments, unlike the HeyJiaYu and SEAFLO porcelain model. Buyers also need to use compatible cleaners and seal lubricants, and a hand sprayer is not included.
Pros:- Space-saving shape allows close mounting to the wall
- 18-inch seat height provides a taller position than standard-height designs
- Residential-size SloClose seat and cover
- Foot pedal controls both water addition and flushing
Cons:- Hand sprayer is not included
- Requires recommended cleaners and seal lubricants to avoid damage
- No adjustable water-flow feature is specified
Best for: RV owners with limited bathroom clearance who want a close-to-wall installation, taller-than-standard seating, and a residential-size soft-close seat.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a supplied hand sprayer, adjustable water flow, or a toilet with a stated extra-tall 20-inch seat.
- Brand:Thetford
- Model:31835
- Installation:Floor-mounted
- Flush type:Foot pedal
- Seat height:18 inches
- Dimensions:20.63 × 18.13 × 15.5 inches (D × W × H)
- Material:Polypropylene
- Weight:10.4 pounds
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Choose the Aqua-Magic VI if wall clearance and a familiar soft-close seat matter more than extra-tall seating or adjustable flush control.”
HeyJiaYu 20-Inch High-Profile RV Gravity-Flush Toilet
The HeyJiaYu is the clearest fit here for RV owners who want a 20-inch seat height and a home-like sitting position. Its foot pedal adds water with a partial press and activates the gravity flush when pressed fully, combining water control and flushing in one mechanism. The listed 441-pound support capacity and HDPE construction may appeal to buyers prioritizing a stated load limit and a lightweight RV installation. Compared with the Thetford Aqua-Magic VI, it sits two inches higher, but its plastic seat is less residential in feel than the Thetford’s SloClose seat. The description also cites broad bowl coverage and water-saving design without providing a quantified water-use figure. Since it is floor-mounted, fit and installation still depend on the RV’s existing setup.
Pros:- 20-inch seating height offers a notably elevated sitting position
- Foot pedal can add water or activate the gravity flush
- HDPE construction keeps the listed unit weight to 11.5 pounds
- Rated to support up to 441 pounds
Cons:- Plastic seat may feel less refined than the Thetford Aqua-Magic VI’s SloClose seat
- Floor-mounted installation requires a compatible RV floor and plumbing setup
- Water-saving performance is not quantified in the provided specifications
Best for: Taller RV users and buyers who want a high seat, a foot pedal that separates water addition from flushing, and a published weight capacity.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prefer a soft-close residential seat or need a compact, low-profile toilet for a small RV bathroom.
- Brand:HeyJiaYu
- Model:HJY-22GFT001
- Flush type:Gravity flush with foot pedal
- Material:HDPE
- Seat material:Plastic
- Dimensions:19.12 × 15.56 × 20.06 inches (D × W × H)
- Weight:11.5 pounds
- Maximum supported weight:441 pounds
- Installation:Floor-mounted
Our verdict“Pick the HeyJiaYu if extra-tall seating and a stated weight capacity outweigh your preference for a soft-close seat.”
Shineforu Gravity Flush RV Toilet with Foot Pedal, White
The Shineforu makes a practical case as a replacement kit: it includes the floor flange and mounting hardware, along with the seat and bowl, reducing the chance of discovering mid-installation that key mounting pieces are missing. Its triple-jet gravity flush and foot-pedal operation give it a distinct flushing setup compared with the simpler pedal descriptions for the Thetford Aqua-Magic VI and HeyJiaYu. The standard-height, elongated design may suit buyers who want a familiar seat position rather than the HeyJiaYu’s 20-inch perch. The tradeoff is its ABS plastic construction and standard height, which may not satisfy buyers seeking a more substantial bowl or elevated seating. The supplied hardware is useful, but buyers should still confirm that the toilet’s dimensions and floor connection match their RV.
Pros:- Triple-jet gravity-flush system is a distinct flushing feature
- Foot-pedal operation avoids manual flushing
- Includes floor flange and mounting hardware
- Elongated, standard-height design
Cons:- ABS plastic construction may feel less substantial than porcelain
- Standard height may be uncomfortable for buyers who prefer residential-height seating
- No warranty or adjustable water-flow detail is provided
Best for: RV owners replacing a floor-mounted toilet who want the flange and mounting hardware included and prefer standard-height seating.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a porcelain bowl, a stated taller seat height, or a residential-style soft-close seat.
- Brand:Shineforu
- Model:Rv-1001
- Material:ABS plastic
- Flush system:Triple-jet gravity flush
- Flush mechanism:Foot pedal
- Shape:Elongated
- Height:Standard
- Dimensions:19.09 × 15.55 × 19.88 inches (D × W × H)
- Included components:Floor flange, mounting hardware, seat, and toilet bowl
Our verdict“Choose the Shineforu when an included flange and mounting hardware simplify a standard-height RV toilet replacement.”
SEAFLO RV Toilet with Foot Pedal Gravity Flush and Soft-Close Seat
SEAFLO’s plastic model focuses on comfort without moving to porcelain: it pairs an 18.4-inch residential-height seat with an oversized, anti-stick bowl and soft-close lid. That combination makes it a more comfort-oriented choice than the standard-height Shineforu, while remaining distinct from the SEAFLO porcelain model’s elongated ceramic bowl and adjustable water flow. Its foot pedal keeps flushing hands-free, and the four-year limited warranty is longer than the Thetford Aqua-Magic VI’s one-year coverage. Installation needs close attention, though: the toilet calls for a 9.5-inch rough-in and a two-bolt mount, and the floor flange is sold separately. Buyers who want a porcelain bowl or need an all-in-one replacement package may prefer another option in this lineup.
Pros:- 18.4-inch residential-height seat
- Oversized, anti-stick bowl is designed for easier cleanup
- Soft-close seat and lid
- Four-year limited warranty
Cons:- Floor flange is sold separately
- Requires a 9.5-inch rough-in, limiting fit in some RV bathrooms
- Lightweight plastic bowl may not suit buyers who want porcelain
Best for: RV owners who prioritize an oversized bowl, residential-height seating, and a longer stated warranty in a plastic toilet.
Not ideal for: Buyers who cannot verify a 9.5-inch rough-in, want a flange included, or prefer the feel and finish of porcelain.
- Model:SFRTPH-01-01
- Height:18.4 inches
- Dimensions:17.8 × 15.3 × 18.4 inches
- Flush operation:Foot pedal gravity flush
- Bowl:Oversized, anti-stick
- Material:Lightweight durable plastic
- Rough-in:9.5 inches
- Mounting:2-bolt
- Warranty:4-year limited
Our verdict“Choose this SEAFLO if bowl room and residential-height comfort matter more than porcelain construction or a complete flange package.”
SEAFLO Porcelain RV Toilet with Elongated Bowl, 19-Inch Residential Height, Gravity Flush, Foot Pedal, Soft-Close Seat
This SEAFLO is the lineup’s material upgrade: its elongated porcelain bowl offers a different surface and feel from the all-plastic SEAFLO model, while a reinforced lightweight plastic base avoids making the entire toilet ceramic. The 19-inch height is slightly above that model’s 18.4 inches and below the HeyJiaYu’s 20 inches, giving buyers a middle ground on seat height. Its adjustable water-flow gravity flush also offers more control than the product descriptions specify for the Thetford Aqua-Magic VI or Shineforu. A soft-close seat and four-year limited warranty add practical appeal. The compromise is a mixed-material build: the base is plastic, not porcelain, and buyers must confirm plumbing compatibility and handle the installation. The provided details do not list a rough-in measurement.
Pros:- Elongated porcelain bowl is specified to resist stains, odors, and buildup
- Adjustable water flow gives buyers control over flushing
- 19-inch height offers a residential-style seating position
- Soft-close seat and four-year limited warranty
Cons:- Reinforced plastic base may feel less substantial than an all-ceramic design
- Installation requires compatible RV plumbing
- Rough-in measurement is not included in the provided specifications
Best for: RV owners who want an elongated porcelain bowl, adjustable pedal-operated gravity flushing, and a residential-height seat.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking an all-ceramic toilet, a supplied installation service, or a clearly stated rough-in dimension before checking fit.
- Model:SFRTCH-02-01
- Operation:Foot pedal
- Height:19 inches
- Dimensions:20.51 × 14.17 × 19 inches
- Flush system:Gravity flush with adjustable water flow
- Bowl material:Porcelain ceramic
- Base material:Reinforced lightweight plastic
- Warranty:4-year limited
- Included components:Gasket seal, mounting screws, screw covers, instructions, and warranty card
Our verdict“Choose this SEAFLO if an elongated porcelain bowl and adjustable gravity flush are worth accepting a plastic base and checking fit yourself.”

How We Picked
I compared these 15 gravity-flush RV toilets by the details that most affect a real replacement decision: bowl material and shape, overall height, flush-control style, included seat features, and how clearly each model suits compact or more residential-feeling bathrooms. I gave extra weight to specifications that help buyers predict fit and day-to-day use, rather than treating a longer feature list as proof of better performance. Gravity-flush operation is shared across this lineup, so the useful distinctions are the physical design and usability choices around it.
The ranking favors models with a strong balance of comfort, practical features, and clearly stated design details. The Dometic Model 410 takes the top position for its porcelain bowl and chair-height format; the Model 420 ranks as a more specialized pick for buyers who want an elongated porcelain bowl. More basic plastic and less fully specified options remain useful for shoppers who prioritize a particular form factor or control, but they rank lower when the available details offer less basis for comparing fit or materials. Before choosing any model, I would confirm its footprint, mounting pattern, water connection, and clearance against the RV’s existing installation.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Gravity Flush Toilet
Gravity-flush models share a straightforward operating principle, but replacing an RV toilet is still a fit-and-use decision. I would begin with the existing installation and the people using it, then weigh material, seat shape, and controls against the bathroom’s space and maintenance needs.
Check the Installation Before Choosing Features
Start by measuring the current toilet’s footprint, height, mounting points, and distance from surrounding walls or fixtures. A taller model may improve sitting comfort but can crowd a small bathroom or conflict with a shelf, vanity, or door swing. Verify that the replacement’s base and water connection suit the RV rather than assuming that all RV toilets share the same fit. If you are replacing an existing unit, compare its installation details with the new model’s documentation before ordering. A mismatch can turn an otherwise suitable toilet into a plumbing or modification project.
Choose Bowl Material for Your Priorities
Porcelain is the more residential-style choice in this lineup, while plastic-bowl models may appeal when a lighter or simpler unit is preferred. Material alone does not tell you how a toilet will fit or feel, so weigh it alongside bowl shape, height, and the RV’s mounting limits. A porcelain model can be attractive for buyers who want a familiar bathroom feel, but it may not be the right choice if weight or installation compatibility is a primary concern. Plastic can be a sensible practical pick, though shoppers who specifically want a porcelain bowl should not treat the two materials as interchangeable. Check the manufacturer’s cleaning and care guidance before using products that could damage the surface.
Match Height and Bowl Shape to the Bathroom
Seat height affects how easily different household members can sit down and stand up, while bowl shape affects both comfort and the room it occupies. Residential-height options can feel closer to a home toilet, but that extra height may not work for every RV layout or user. An elongated bowl can add room where the bathroom has enough clearance; a round bowl is often the safer fit in a compact space. Measure the available depth and check the seat height rather than relying on labels such as high-profile or residential height alone. When multiple people share the RV, prioritize a fit that works for the least comfortable user without obstructing movement.
Pick a Flush Control You Can Use Comfortably
A foot pedal keeps the flush control separate from the seat area and may suit buyers who prefer hands-free operation, but pedal position and ease of movement still matter. Other control arrangements may be a better match for someone who has trouble using a pedal or wants a different operating routine. A sprayer attachment can provide another cleaning option, yet it adds a component and connection that should be checked against the RV’s plumbing and available space. Do not assume that every attachment is included just because a product name mentions a feature; confirm the listed package contents. The best control is the one that fits your mobility, habits, and installation.
Balance Comfort Features Against Maintenance
A soft-close seat can reduce sudden slamming, which may be welcome in a small shared RV bathroom, but it does not determine flush performance. Removable or replaceable seat components and accessible parts may matter more over time than a convenience feature used at every visit. Ask whether replacement seats, seals, and other service parts are available for the specific model. Follow guidance for cleaning the bowl and maintaining seals, and avoid assuming household products are suitable for RV components. A simpler toilet can be the better ownership choice when repair access and straightforward upkeep matter more than added features.
Know When a More Residential Feel Is Worth It
Paying attention to bowl material, shape, and height makes sense when the toilet is used frequently or household comfort is a priority. A porcelain, elongated, residential-height option may better suit that goal, provided the bathroom and plumbing can accommodate it. For occasional trips, a smaller or plastic-bowl model may meet the need without adding features that do not matter to your routine. Think about the RV’s payload and how the bathroom is used before choosing a heavier or larger design. The useful upgrade is not the one with the longest feature list; it is the one whose added comfort fits your space and travel pattern.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I replace my existing RV toilet with any gravity-flush model?
No. Gravity-flush operation does not mean every model shares the same base, mounting pattern, height, or water connection. Measure the existing installation and compare those details with the replacement’s specifications before purchasing. Also check the toilet’s footprint and clearance from doors, walls, and nearby fixtures. If the mounting or plumbing differs, you may need adapters or installation changes, so confirm compatibility before removing the old unit.
Should I choose porcelain or plastic for an RV toilet?
Choose based on the tradeoff you care about most, rather than assuming one material is right for every RV. Porcelain models in this roundup offer a more residential-style bowl, while plastic models may suit buyers who prefer a lighter or simpler unit. Weight, installation fit, cleaning guidance, and the specific bowl design all matter alongside material. Compare the manufacturer’s specifications and care instructions, especially if the toilet will replace a different type of bowl. The Dometic Model 410 and 420 are porcelain options; the Model 400 is a plastic-bowl alternative.
Is a 19- or 20-inch toilet height comfortable in a small RV bathroom?
It can be comfortable for users who prefer a higher seat, but the measurement alone does not tell you whether the toilet will fit the room. Check the seat height and total installed clearance against your current setup, including nearby counters, walls, and doors. A taller toilet may also feel less suitable for children or shorter users. The 20-inch HeyJiaYu and residential-height models are worth checking closely before ordering rather than treating extra height as a universal benefit. If users have different needs, prioritize access for everyone who regularly uses the bathroom.
Is an elongated bowl worth choosing over a round bowl?
An elongated bowl may offer a more familiar residential feel, but it generally needs more front-to-back room. In a compact RV bathroom, that extra length can interfere with movement or nearby fixtures. A round bowl may be the more practical choice when space is tight, even if an elongated shape is your preference at home. Measure the available depth and compare it with the toilet’s dimensions before deciding. The Dometic Model 420 and several SEAFLO models provide elongated options, while the Dometic Model 410 has a round bowl.
What should I check before buying a toilet with a sprayer attachment?
Confirm whether the sprayer is included and how it connects to the toilet’s water supply. Check that the RV’s existing plumbing and bathroom layout can accommodate the connection and the sprayer hose without restricting movement. Consider where the hose will sit when not in use and whether its reach suits the bowl. A sprayer adds a cleaning option, but it also adds a component that may need care or replacement. If you would rarely use it, a simpler model may be a better fit for your setup.
Conclusion
For most buyers seeking a balanced gravity-flush RV toilet, I recommend the Dometic Model 410 as the best overall: its porcelain bowl, 18-inch chair-height format, and soft-close seat combine familiar comfort with practical details. The Dometic Model 400 is my best value-style choice for shoppers who want a round, plastic-bowl design and do not need porcelain. For a more residential bowl shape, the Dometic Model 420 is the best premium-leaning pick in this group, while the Model 410 is also the easiest starting point for buyers who want a straightforward shortlist. If your priority is a particular need, choose among the SEAFLO elongated porcelain models for that bowl style, a foot-pedal model for pedal control, or a residential-height option only after checking clearance. My final recommendation is to confirm mounting, plumbing, and room dimensions first; those details matter more than any feature that cannot fit your RV.


















