For a thornless rose that combines fragrance, repeat blooms, and flexible light tolerance, Zephirine Drouhin is my strongest all-around pick. Gardeners with a sunny, sturdy arbor may prefer Peggy Martin for its long bloom season and vigorous growth, while Raspberry Cream Twirl offers a smaller-container starting point and continual flowers. The main tradeoffs are space, sunlight, and how established the plant is when it arrives: a thornless rose can still become a large climber, and the smallest shipment may take longer to make an impact.
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
These five choices are all climbing roses described as thornless or nearly thornless, but they are not interchangeable. I rank them by how clearly their details support a useful garden decision: mature dimensions, bloom traits, growing conditions, and delivery format. Below, I explain which one fits a fence, patio, trellis, or sunny garden—and who should choose a different rose.
Complete the kit
![[Genuine] Waterdrop PF-01A Water Filter Replacement for W...](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41+5tl9EiKL._SX342_SY445_QL70_FMwebp_.jpg)
Key Takeaways
- Best overall: Zephirine Drouhin pairs fragrant pink repeat blooms with some tolerance for open shade, but its mature size calls for substantial support.
- Best for a large, sunny structure: Peggy Martin is described as thornless and blooms from spring through fall, yet it can reach 15–20 feet.
- Best smaller-container start: Raspberry Cream Twirl arrives in a 1-gallon pot and can bloom continually, though it needs full sun and a season to climb.
- Best established arrival: The Green Promise Farms Zephirine Drouhin comes in a 3-gallon trade pot and is listed as fully rooted, but planting conditions still matter.
- Best for a highly petaled flower: The pink-and-magenta own-root rose has blooms described as having 100+ petals, but arrives in a notably small 4-inch pot.
| Climbing Rose ‘Zephirine Drouhin’ – 3-Gallon Pot |  | Best Overall | Plant form: Climbing rose | Flower color: Deep pink | Canes: Nearly thornless | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Peggy Martin Climbing Rose Live Plant, 16–28 Inches Tall, 3-Gallon Pot |  | Best for Large Sunny Structures | Plant form: Climbing rose | Flower color: Coral pink | Canes: Thornless | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Heirloom Raspberry Cream Twirl Climbing Rose, Live Own-Root Plant |  | Best Smaller-Container Start | Plant form: Climbing rose | Root type: Own-root | Canes: Nearly thornless | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Rosa ‘Zéphirine Drouhin’ Climbing Rose, Thornless Pink Flowers, 3-Gallon Pot |  | Best Fully Rooted Arrival | Plant form: Climbing rose | Flower color: Pink | Canes: Thornless | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Thornless Pink and Magenta Climbing Rose Plant |  | Best for Highly Petaled Pink-and-Magenta Blooms | Plant form: Climbing rose | Root type: Own-root | Flower color and form: Pink and magenta; fully double | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| thornless rose bushe | Plant form | Canes | Mature size | Hardiness zones |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Climbing Rose ‘Zephirine Drouh | Climbing rose | Nearly thornless | About 120–180 in. tall; 60–96 in. spread | 5–9 |
| Peggy Martin Climbing Rose Liv | Climbing rose | Thornless | — | 6–10 |
| Heirloom Raspberry Cream Twirl | Climbing rose | Nearly thornless | 10–11+ ft. tall × 4–5 ft. wide | 6–10 |
| Rosa ‘Zéphirine Drouhin’ Climb | Climbing rose | Thornless | 8–12 ft. tall × 8–12 ft. wide | 4–8 |
| Thornless Pink and Magenta Cli | Climbing rose | — | About 10 ft. tall × 6 ft. wide | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Climbing Rose ‘Zephirine Drouhin’ – 3-Gallon Pot
Zephirine Drouhin is my best overall choice because it combines three qualities that are difficult to balance in a climbing rose: deep-pink fragrant flowers, repeat bloom cycles, and canes described as nearly thornless. That near-thornless wording is a little more cautious than the fully thornless claims attached to Peggy Martin and the other Zephirine Drouhin listing. Even so, it is a compelling fit where people pass close to the plant, such as along a patio border or beside a path.
Its biggest advantage over the Green Promise Farms Zephirine Drouhin is the stated flexibility for full sun to part shade; the other listing says full sun with tolerance for open shade. That distinction may help when the planting site gets less than a full day of direct sun, though neither description makes this a deep-shade rose. The listed hardiness range is zones 5–9, while the other listing gives zones 4–8, so buyers should check the nursery’s guidance for their region rather than assume the two entries give identical climate advice.
The tradeoff is scale. A stated height of about 150 inches, with a broader description of 120–180 inches and a spread of 60–96 inches, means this is a real climber, not a compact shrub for a small pot. I would choose it for a fence or strong trellis where its fragrance and repeat blooms can be enjoyed, and skip it where regular watering, deadheading, and annual pruning would be hard to keep up with.
Pros:- Deep-pink flowers are described as highly fragrant.
- Repeat bloom cycles can extend the display through the season.
- Nearly thornless canes are a useful fit beside patios and pathways.
- Tolerates full sun to part shade, offering more site flexibility than the full-sun-only listings.
Cons:- Mature size can reach roughly 10–15 feet tall with a broad spread, so it needs substantial room and support.
- Regular watering, deadheading, and annual pruning add ongoing work.
- The listing says nearly thornless rather than unequivocally thornless.
Best for: Gardeners who want a fragrant, repeat-blooming climber near a patio or path and can provide a large support and regular care.
Not ideal for: Small-space growers, gardeners seeking a confirmed fully thornless cane, or anyone unable to water and prune a vigorous climber.
- Plant form:Climbing rose
- Flower color:Deep pink
- Canes:Nearly thornless
- Mature size:About 120–180 in. tall; 60–96 in. spread
- Light:Full sun to part shade
- Hardiness zones:5–9
- Bloom habit:Repeat bloom cycles
- Container:3-gallon pot
Our verdict“I rank this first for fragrance, repeat flowering, and light flexibility, provided you have the room to manage a large climber.”
Peggy Martin Climbing Rose Live Plant, 16–28 Inches Tall, 3-Gallon Pot
Peggy Martin is the strongest match for a big, sunny structure when a long stated flowering season matters more than keeping growth compact. This rose is described as thornless, with coral-pink double blooms from spring through fall, and can grow up to 15–20 feet. Against the more moderately sized pink-and-magenta rose in this group, Peggy Martin is the more convincing choice for covering an arbor or long fence—if that structure can support the growth.
Its main point of difference from Zephirine Drouhin is the combination of explicitly thornless canes and a spring-to-fall bloom window. Zephirine Drouhin brings stronger fragrance detail and some shade tolerance, whereas Peggy Martin is listed for full sun only. If a planting spot is partly shaded, I would favor Zephirine Drouhin; for a sunny, humid garden with a large support, Peggy Martin’s stated heat and humidity tolerance gives it a clearer role.
The plant arrives in a 3-gallon pot at approximately 16–28 inches tall, a more substantial format than the 1-gallon Raspberry Cream Twirl or the 4-inch pink-and-magenta plant. That does not remove the need to establish it carefully, and the listed mature height can outgrow a small trellis quickly. Choose it for coverage, not containment: full sun and ample support are non-negotiable based on the supplied details.
Pros:- Described as thornless, making pruning and handling easier than thorny climbers.
- Coral-pink double blooms are listed from spring through fall.
- Heat and humidity tolerance suit warm growing conditions.
- A 3-gallon pot and 16–28-inch arrival height provide a larger starting plant than the smaller-container options.
Cons:- Can reach 15–20 feet and needs a substantial structure and ample space.
- Listed for full sun, with no stated shade tolerance.
- The supplied details do not specify fragrance.
Best for: Gardeners in zones 6–10 with a sunny site, a sturdy arbor or fence, and room for a vigorous rose that may reach 15–20 feet.
Not ideal for: Anyone with part shade, a small trellis, or a preference for a compact rose with clearly stated fragrance.
- Plant form:Climbing rose
- Flower color:Coral pink
- Canes:Thornless
- Delivery size:16–28 in. tall in a 3-gallon pot
- Mature height:Up to 15–20 ft.
- Bloom period:Spring through fall
- Light:Full sun
- Hardiness zones:6–10
Our verdict“I recommend Peggy Martin for sunny, spacious sites where long-season color and vigorous coverage outweigh the need to control size.”
Heirloom Raspberry Cream Twirl Climbing Rose, Live Own-Root Plant
Raspberry Cream Twirl makes the most sense when you want a climbing rose in a smaller initial package and are comfortable giving it time to fill out. It arrives at 12–15 inches in a 1-gallon container, compared with the two 3-gallon Zephirine Drouhin plants and Peggy Martin. That smaller start may suit a planter or a new trellis, but it is not the pick for an instant screen or a large display on arrival.
The listing describes a continual bloom from spring to fall, light fragrance, and nearly thornless canes. That makes it a useful alternative to Peggy Martin for a longer-season display in a smaller container format, though Peggy Martin is described as fully thornless and better suited to a large structure. Raspberry Cream Twirl’s mature size of 10–11 feet or taller by 4–5 feet still requires a support plan; its modest delivery size should not be mistaken for a compact mature habit.
It is an own-root plant, which means its roots, stems, and flowers are from the same variety according to the supplied description. Its listed zones are 6–10, and it needs full sun with moderate watering. The seller notes that it may arrive partially defoliated for shipping health, so I would not judge the plant solely by leaves at unpacking. Skip it if your site is shaded or you want a large, established plant with less growing-on time.
Pros:- Continual bloom is listed from spring to fall.
- Light fragrance and nearly thornless canes add appeal near a seating area.
- Own-root growth keeps roots, stems, and flowers from the same variety.
- Can be grown in outdoor gardens, planters, or pots.
Cons:- Arrives in a 1-gallon container at 12–15 inches tall, smaller than the 3-gallon picks.
- Requires full sun and moderate watering.
- May arrive partially defoliated, and mature growth can exceed 10 feet.
Best for: Gardeners who want a nearly thornless, continually flowering climber in a 1-gallon pot for a sunny garden, planter, or smaller support.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking an established, large plant on arrival, a rose for part shade, or a climber with a clearly stated fully thornless rather than nearly thornless cane.
- Plant form:Climbing rose
- Root type:Own-root
- Canes:Nearly thornless
- Container and arrival height:1 gallon; 12–15 in.
- Mature size:10–11+ ft. tall × 4–5 ft. wide
- Bloom habit:Continual bloom, spring to fall
- Light and water:Full sun; moderate watering
- Hardiness zones:6–10
Our verdict“I would choose Raspberry Cream Twirl for a sunny site and a smaller initial plant, not for immediate coverage or shade.”
Rosa ‘Zéphirine Drouhin’ Climbing Rose, Thornless Pink Flowers, 3-Gallon Pot
This second Zephirine Drouhin listing stands out for its stated arrival condition: it comes fully rooted in a 3-gallon trade pot and can be planted when local conditions allow. That gives it a different advantage from the first Zephirine Drouhin, whose description also specifies a 3-gallon pot but focuses more on part-shade tolerance and regular care. For a buyer prioritizing a rooted, ready-to-plant format, this listing is the clearer choice.
The rose itself has fragrant pink flowers, thornless stems, and reblooming behavior. Those traits put it close to the first-ranked option, but its stated zones are 4–8 rather than 5–9, and its mature dimensions are 8–12 feet high and wide. Its listing gives full sun with tolerance for open shade, while the first listing says full sun to part shade. I would treat both as roses that can accept some shade, not as suitable for a deeply shaded planting spot.
Timing matters here. The listing warns against planting in frigid winter weather or drought, and notes that a late-fall or winter arrival may be dormant without leaves. Dormancy is not the same as a failed plant, but buyers need to be ready to wait for suitable planting weather and growth. The bloom-period field says fall even though the description says the rose reblooms; since those details do not give a fully consistent season, I would not choose it solely for a specific bloom calendar.
Pros:- Arrives fully rooted in a 3-gallon trade pot.
- Fragrant pink flowers and thornless stems suit a low-contact planting area.
- Described as reblooming, extending its appeal beyond a single flush.
- Tolerates open shade as well as full sun.
Cons:- May arrive dormant without leaves in late fall or winter.
- Should not be planted during frigid weather or drought conditions.
- The supplied bloom-period field and rebloom description do not give a clear, matching season.
Best for: Gardeners who want a fully rooted 3-gallon Zephirine Drouhin and can plant it during suitable weather in zones 4–8.
Not ideal for: Anyone who needs an immediate leafy display in winter, must plant during drought or freezing weather, or wants the listing’s bloom timing to be unambiguous.
- Plant form:Climbing rose
- Flower color:Pink
- Canes:Thornless
- Container:3-gallon trade pot
- Mature size:8–12 ft. tall × 8–12 ft. wide
- Light:Full sun; tolerates open shade
- Hardiness zones:4–8
- Watering:Moderate
Our verdict“I rank this as the best established arrival for buyers who value a fully rooted plant and can wait for appropriate planting conditions.”
Thornless Pink and Magenta Climbing Rose Plant
This own-root rose is the most distinctive flower choice in the group: its blooms are described as pink and magenta, fragrant, fully double, and made up of more than 100 petals. That detail separates it from the simpler color descriptions for Peggy Martin and Zephirine Drouhin. I would put it on a trellis or gazebo where the flower form can be seen at close range, rather than choosing it primarily for rapid coverage.
The listing calls it thornless and gives a mature size of about 10 feet tall by 6 feet wide, a more contained outline than Peggy Martin’s potential 15–20 feet. It is also listed for zones 5–10, a wider range than Raspberry Cream Twirl’s 6–10. However, this plant arrives at approximately 3–5 inches tall in a 4-inch pot, much smaller than the 1-gallon Raspberry Cream Twirl and the 3-gallon plants. Buyers should expect a longer establishment period before it can make much of a visual contribution.
It needs at least four hours of direct sunlight, and the listing says it blooms in late spring; unlike the listings that specify repeat or continual blooms, it does not promise a long-season cycle. The seller also notes that it may arrive partially defoliated. Its appeal is flower detail, not the largest starting plant or the clearest rebloom claim, so I would pass if quick screening or prolonged flowering is the main goal.
Pros:- Flowers are described as fragrant, fully double, and over 100 petals.
- Listed as thornless and suitable for training on fences, gazebos, or trellises.
- Own-root plant is described as hardy and true to variety.
- Mature size of approximately 10 by 6 feet is more contained than Peggy Martin.
Cons:- Arrives only about 3–5 inches tall in a 4-inch pot, much smaller than the other plants.
- Needs at least four hours of direct sunlight.
- Late-spring bloom is stated, but repeat flowering is not specified; partial defoliation is also possible.
Best for: Gardeners who value fragrant, fully double pink-and-magenta flowers and can start with a very small own-root plant.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a large plant on arrival, want a stated spring-to-fall bloom season, or have a site with little direct sunlight.
- Plant form:Climbing rose
- Root type:Own-root
- Flower color and form:Pink and magenta; fully double
- Petals per bloom:More than 100
- Fragrance:Described as very pleasant
- Mature size:About 10 ft. tall × 6 ft. wide
- Delivery format:4-inch pot; approximately 3–5 in. tall
- Hardiness zones and light:Zones 5–10; at least 4 hours of direct sun
Our verdict“I recommend this rose for its unusual, petal-rich flowers, not for buyers who want a large arrival or a clearly documented repeat-bloom season.”
How We Picked
I compared these roses as thornless climbing plants, not simply as pink-flowered garden roses. The most useful distinctions are how thornless the listing says the canes are, how large each rose may grow, whether it reblooms, and what the buyer needs to provide for it to thrive. A plant described as nearly thornless is not quite the same claim as one described as thornless, so I preserve that distinction rather than treating every option as identical.
I also weighed practical growing and arrival details. A 3-gallon rooted plant may be a more substantial starting point than a 4-inch pot, while a compact arrival can still suit a gardener who is willing to wait and nurture it. Hardiness zones, light requirements, watering guidance, and seasonal bloom information help reveal whether a rose is a plausible fit for a particular site. Where the supplied details disagree or leave a point unclear—such as a bloom period described differently across listings—I avoid turning that uncertainty into a firm promise.
The order reflects overall usefulness and clarity of fit, not a claim that one rose will outperform another in every garden. Zephirine Drouhin ranks first for its blend of fragrance, reblooming, and adaptability to full sun or open shade. Peggy Martin follows for its lengthy stated bloom window and clear role on large structures. Raspberry Cream Twirl is a useful smaller-container option, while the second Zephirine Drouhin listing distinguishes itself through its fully rooted 3-gallon delivery. The final pink-and-magenta rose offers a distinctive flower description but has less delivery scale and fewer growing details. All rankings should be read alongside each buyer’s climate, space, and planting conditions.
| thornless rose bushe | Flower color | Canes | Light |
|---|---|---|---|
| Climbing Rose ‘Zephirine Drouh | Deep pink | Nearly thornless | Full sun to part shade |
| Peggy Martin Climbing Rose Liv | Coral pink | Thornless | Full sun |
| Heirloom Raspberry Cream Twirl | — | Nearly thornless | — |
| Rosa ‘Zéphirine Drouhin’ Climb | Pink | Thornless | Full sun; tolerates open shade |
| Thornless Pink and Magenta Cli | — | — | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing 3 Best Thornless Rose Bushes
With these five options, I would start by matching the rose to its eventual support and growing site. All are climbing roses, so their small delivery size can be misleading: the mature plants need room, sunlight, and a structure that can handle their stems. Then compare the exact thorn claim and bloom habit. Nearly thornless, thornless, and repeat-blooming are different promises, and the listing language matters when you are choosing for a busy walkway or a long flowering display.
Decide how much space the mature rose can use
Do not size a climbing rose by the pot it arrives in. Peggy Martin may reach 15–20 feet, the first Zephirine Drouhin listing gives a potential height up to 180 inches and a broad spread, and Raspberry Cream Twirl can exceed 10 feet. The pink-and-magenta own-root rose is listed at about 10 by 6 feet, but its small arrival size does not mean it will remain a tiny plant. I would measure the fence, arbor, or trellis and leave enough room for pruning and airflow. If the structure is short or narrow, avoid the most vigorous option rather than relying on frequent cutting to keep it small.
Read thorn claims literally
Some listings say thornless; the two first-listed roses use nearly thornless. That wording is worth noting around paths, play areas, and seating spaces. A nearly thornless cane may be easier to handle than a thorny rose, but it should not be treated as a guarantee that every stem is completely free of prickles. If minimizing contact risk is your priority, the explicit thornless descriptions for Peggy Martin, the second Zephirine Drouhin, and the pink-and-magenta plant are stronger wording. Regardless of the claim, use care when pruning and tying a climber.
Match bloom expectations to the listing
Peggy Martin is described as blooming from spring through fall, and Raspberry Cream Twirl is listed as continually blooming through the same period. Both Zephirine Drouhin descriptions mention reblooming, though one listing gives an unclear fall period in its structured details. The pink-and-magenta rose is described as blooming in late spring, without a repeat-bloom claim. If a long display is central to your decision, I would favor the options with an explicit extended-season description and avoid assuming that an unspecified cycle will repeat.
Check sun exposure and local hardiness guidance
Peggy Martin, Raspberry Cream Twirl, and the pink-and-magenta rose all call for substantial direct sunlight; the last specifies at least four hours. The Zephirine Drouhin listings allow some shade, but their descriptions still favor full sun. Zone ranges also differ: the first Zephirine Drouhin is listed for zones 5–9, the other for 4–8, and the remaining roses span 6–10 or 5–10. Because the two listings for the same rose differ, I would verify suitability with the seller or a local nursery before purchase, especially near a zone boundary.
Use pot size and arrival condition to set expectations
The two Zephirine Drouhin plants and Peggy Martin arrive in 3-gallon pots, while Raspberry Cream Twirl is in a 1-gallon container and the pink-and-magenta plant is listed in a 4-inch pot at only 3–5 inches tall. Larger containers offer a more substantial starting format, but do not guarantee flowers immediately after planting. Dormancy or partial leaf loss can also occur: one Zephirine Drouhin may arrive without leaves in cold-season shipping, and two smaller options may arrive partially defoliated. I would judge arrival condition in light of season and planting instructions, not by foliage alone.
Plan for water, support, and pruning
These are not maintenance-free plants. The first Zephirine Drouhin listing calls for regular watering, deadheading, and annual pruning; Raspberry Cream Twirl lists moderate watering, while the other products provide less specific care detail. A sturdy trellis, fence, or arbor is part of the purchase decision, not an optional extra for a vigorous climber. Before ordering, make sure you can water during establishment and guide new canes onto the support. If your goal is a hands-off rose in a confined bed, none of these climbing options is the most sensible fit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which rose is the best choice for a walkway or patio?
I would start with Zephirine Drouhin if fragrance and some tolerance for part shade are priorities, but note that its listing says nearly thornless rather than fully thornless. For the clearest explicit thornless claim, Peggy Martin or the second Zephirine Drouhin is a better match on paper. Any climber beside a path still needs to be trained and pruned so its growth does not obstruct people.
Are all five roses completely thornless?
No. The listings for the first Zephirine Drouhin and Raspberry Cream Twirl say nearly thornless, while Peggy Martin, the second Zephirine Drouhin, and the pink-and-magenta rose are described as thornless. I would keep that wording distinction in mind if the plant will be close to children, pets, or a frequently used walkway; product descriptions do not replace careful handling and pruning.
Which option offers the longest stated bloom season?
Peggy Martin and Raspberry Cream Twirl have the clearest spring-to-fall bloom descriptions. The Zephirine Drouhin roses are described as reblooming, but one listing gives a fall period in its structured details, so I would not treat its exact timing as equally clear. The pink-and-magenta rose is listed for late-spring blooms without a stated repeat cycle.
Can I grow one of these roses in partial shade?
The two Zephirine Drouhin listings are the best candidates for some shade: one says it tolerates part shade, and the other says it tolerates open shade. The remaining options are presented as full-sun roses, with the pink-and-magenta listing asking for at least four hours of direct sunlight. Some shade tolerance does not mean a rose will flower well in a dim location, so choose the sunniest suitable planting site available.
Should I worry if a rose arrives without leaves?
Not automatically. The second Zephirine Drouhin may arrive dormant without leaves in late fall or winter, and Raspberry Cream Twirl and the pink-and-magenta plant may arrive partially defoliated. Dormancy and shipping-related leaf loss are not the same as a dead plant, but follow the seller’s care and planting instructions, check the plant promptly, and avoid planting during unsuitable conditions such as freezing weather or drought.
Conclusion
For most gardeners, I would choose the first Zephirine Drouhin for fragrant pink flowers, repeat bloom, and some part-shade flexibility—provided its large mature spread fits the site. Choose Peggy Martin if you have a sunny, sturdy structure and want an explicitly thornless rose with a stated spring-to-fall bloom season. Pick Raspberry Cream Twirl for a smaller-container start and continual blooms, or the second Zephirine Drouhin if a fully rooted 3-gallon arrival matters more than clear seasonal timing.
The pink-and-magenta own-root rose is my choice for gardeners drawn to highly petaled, fragrant flowers who are willing to start with a very small plant. Whichever option you choose, check your hardiness zone, measure the support against the mature dimensions, and be realistic about sunlight and pruning. Those practical matches matter more than the plant’s modest size in its shipping pot.
