Recycled toilet paper varies most in softness, ply, sheet count, and how much storage a pack demands. I rank Who Gives A Crap 100% Recycled Toilet Paper as the best overall for its clearly stated 330 sheets per roll, while Aria 3-Ply is the standout for shoppers who want a thicker, more cushioned sheet. For households focused on stocking up, Seventh Generation’s 60-roll pack offers a large supply of 2-ply tissue, though it calls for ample storage. The main tradeoff is between a thicker feel and the space or sheet-count clarity of larger packs. Read on for the full breakdown and guidance on choosing a pack that fits your household.
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Who Gives A Crap is the most clearly specified option in this lineup: its 330 sheets per roll make roll capacity easier to compare than products listed mainly by roll count.
- Aria’s 3-ply rolls prioritize thickness, making them the clearest choice for shoppers who prefer a more substantial sheet over a basic 2-ply format.
- Seventh Generation offers the largest stated pack at 60 rolls, but buyers should check storage space and compare sheet counts where available before treating roll count as value.
- Pack size changes the buying decision: Aria’s six-roll pack is a lower-commitment way to try its 3-ply format, while the 24-, 48-, and 60-roll options suit restocking.
- The two Seventh Generation 48-roll listings appear to be the same product; I treat them as one distinct choice rather than implying that duplicate entries offer different performance.
| Aria 100% Recycled Toilet Paper, 24 Rolls, 3-Ply |  | Best Overall | Material: 100% recycled fiber | Ply: 3-ply | Roll count: 24 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 365 by Whole Foods Market 100% Recycled Bath Tissue, 24 Double Rolls |  | Best for Post-Consumer Content | Material: 100% recycled paper; 80% post-consumer material | Ply: 2-ply | Pack: 24 double rolls | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Toilet Paper, 60 Rolls |  | Best Bulk Supply | Material: 100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber | Ply: 2-ply | Roll count: 60 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Who Gives A Crap 100% Recycled Toilet Paper, 24 Rolls, 330 Sheets per Roll |  | Best for Long-Lasting Rolls | Material: 100% recycled paper | Virgin trees: None used | Ply: 3-ply | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 48 Rolls |  | Best for Septic and Low-Flow Toilets | Material: 100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber | Ply: 2-ply | Roll count: 48 (two packs of 24) | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Aria 100% Recycled 3-Ply Toilet Paper, 6 Rolls |  | Best Small-Pack 3-Ply Pick | Material: 100% recycled fiber | Ply: 3-ply | Rolls per pack: 6 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 48 Rolls |  | Best Bulk Recycled Pick | Material: 100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber | Ply: 2-ply | Rolls per pack: 48 (4 packs of 12) | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| recycled toilet paper | Material | Ply | Sheets per roll | Roll count |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aria 100% Recycled Toilet Pape | 100% recycled fiber | 3-ply | 264 | 24 |
| 365 by Whole Foods Market 100% | 100% recycled paper; 80% post-consumer material | 2-ply | 260 | — |
| Seventh Generation 100% Recycl | 100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber | 2-ply | 500 | 60 |
| Who Gives A Crap 100% Recycled | 100% recycled paper | 3-ply | 330 | 24 |
| Seventh Generation 100% Recycl | 100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber | 2-ply | 240 | 48 (two packs of 24) |
| Aria 100% Recycled 3-Ply Toile | 100% recycled fiber | 3-ply | 264 | — |
| Seventh Generation 100% Recycl | 100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber | 2-ply | 240 | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Aria 100% Recycled Toilet Paper, 24 Rolls, 3-Ply
For buyers who want recycled content without giving up a sturdier feel, Aria’s 3-ply construction makes this my most balanced pick. It uses 100% recycled fiber, has no added inks, dyes, or fragrances, and provides 264 sheets per roll. The brand describes it as thicker and stronger when wet than leading recycled options, a useful distinction for households that find some recycled tissue too fragile. Compared with the 365 by Whole Foods Market 2-ply, Aria puts more emphasis on thickness, while 365 specifies that 80% of its recycled material is post-consumer. Aria also uses recyclable paper packaging and supports reforestation. The tradeoff is that recycled fiber may feel less soft than virgin-pulp tissue, and 24 rolls offer less total sheet capacity than Seventh Generation’s 60-roll pack.
Pros:- Made with 100% recycled fiber
- Three-ply build is intended to add thickness and wet strength
- No added inks, dyes, or fragrances
- Recyclable paper packaging and a reforestation partnership
Cons:- Recycled fiber may feel less soft than virgin-pulp alternatives
- At 264 sheets per roll, it offers less per-roll capacity than Who Gives A Crap’s 330-sheet rolls
- The 24-roll pack has fewer total sheets than Seventh Generation’s 60-roll option
Best for: Households seeking 3-ply recycled tissue with no added fragrance or colorants, plus paper packaging.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prioritize a very soft virgin-pulp feel or want the highest total sheet count in one pack.
- Material:100% recycled fiber
- Ply:3-ply
- Roll count:24
- Sheets per roll:264
- Packaging:Recyclable paper
- Added inks, dyes, or fragrances:None
- Septic safe:Yes
Our verdict“Choose Aria if you want a sturdier 3-ply recycled option with paper packaging, and skip it if softness or maximum bulk capacity comes first.”
365 by Whole Foods Market 100% Recycled Bath Tissue, 24 Double Rolls
The clearest reason to choose this 2-ply tissue is its stated recycled-material mix: 100% recycled paper, including 80% post-consumer material. That makes it a more specific fit for buyers who want recycled paper sourced largely from material already used by consumers. It also avoids chlorine bleach and is described as both soft and strong. Compared with Aria’s 3-ply, 365 is the simpler two-ply choice, while Aria makes stronger claims around thickness and wet strength. Each 365 roll has 260 sheets, close to Aria’s 264, but well below Who Gives A Crap’s 330 sheets per roll. The pack contains 24 double rolls, though the available details do not clarify an equivalent total-roll format, and there is no supplied septic-safety information.
Pros:- Made from 100% recycled paper, including 80% post-consumer material
- Whitened without chlorine bleach
- Two-ply tissue is described as soft and strong
- 260 sheets per roll
Cons:- Two-ply construction may feel less substantial than Aria or Who Gives A Crap 3-ply tissue
- No septic-safety information is provided
- Its 260 sheets per roll are fewer than Who Gives A Crap’s 330
Best for: Recycled-paper shoppers who put a high stated share of post-consumer fiber and chlorine-free whitening ahead of ply thickness.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need confirmed septic compatibility, prefer three-ply tissue, or want a clearly stated high sheet count per roll.
- Material:100% recycled paper; 80% post-consumer material
- Ply:2-ply
- Pack:24 double rolls
- Sheets per roll:260
- Total sheets:6,240
- Chlorine bleach:Not used
- Item weight:5.4 pounds
Our verdict“Pick 365 if a high stated share of post-consumer fiber is your priority, but choose a better-documented alternative if septic fit or thicker tissue matters.”
Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Toilet Paper, 60 Rolls
When the aim is to stock up and reduce how often you replenish, this pack’s 30,000 total sheets set it apart from the smaller packs here. It uses 100% recycled paper with at least 50% post-consumer fiber, and the tissue has no added dyes, inks, or fragrances. It is also whitened without chlorine bleach and FSC-certified. Compared with the other Seventh Generation 48-roll pack, this version has 500 sheets per roll rather than 240, giving it substantially more sheet capacity per roll as well as a larger total supply. The tradeoff is storage: 60 rolls take more room than Aria’s 24-roll pack or the 48-roll Seventh Generation option. Its 2-ply format may also feel less substantial than the 3-ply Aria and Who Gives A Crap alternatives.
Pros:- 60 rolls provide 30,000 total sheets
- Made from 100% recycled paper with at least 50% post-consumer fiber
- No added dyes, inks, or fragrances
- FSC-certified and whitened without chlorine bleach
Cons:- The 60-roll pack requires considerable storage space
- Two-ply construction may feel less substantial than Aria or Who Gives A Crap 3-ply tissue
- A large pack may be inconvenient for households with limited room to store supplies
Best for: Large households, shared bathrooms, or shoppers with storage space who want a substantial recycled-paper supply.
Not ideal for: People with limited closet space or buyers who prefer the thicker feel of three-ply tissue.
- Material:100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber
- Ply:2-ply
- Roll count:60
- Sheets per roll:500
- Total sheets:30,000
- Scent:Unscented
- Chlorine bleach:Not used
- Certification:FSC-certified
Our verdict“Choose this Seventh Generation pack when maximum sheet supply matters more than compact storage or three-ply thickness.”
Who Gives A Crap 100% Recycled Toilet Paper, 24 Rolls, 330 Sheets per Roll
330 sheets per roll is the key differentiator here: among these 24-roll choices, Who Gives A Crap offers more sheets per roll than Aria’s 264 and 365’s 260. Its 3-ply construction adds another reason to favor it if you want more capacity without moving to a 48- or 60-roll bulk pack. The paper is made from 100% recycled material with no virgin trees, and the rolls are described as biodegradable. The company also donates 50% of its profits to WASH, which gives the purchase a stated sanitation-charity connection. Compared with Aria, this option has more sheets per roll, while Aria specifies recyclable paper packaging and no added inks, dyes, or fragrances. Product performance details are limited, so buyers who want those specific assurances may prefer Aria.
Pros:- Made from 100% recycled paper with no virgin trees used
- 330 sheets per roll, more than the other 24-roll options listed here
- Three-ply construction
- Biodegradable rolls and a stated donation of 50% of profits to WASH
Cons:- The product details do not specify whether inks, dyes, or fragrances are added
- Septic-safety information is not provided
- The available description gives limited detail about tissue performance
Best for: Households wanting 3-ply recycled tissue with more sheets per roll and an explicit company donation commitment.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want detailed claims about additives, septic compatibility, or packaging materials before choosing.
- Material:100% recycled paper
- Virgin trees:None used
- Ply:3-ply
- Roll count:24
- Sheets per roll:330
- Biodegradable:Yes
- Certification:B Corp certified
- Company donation:50% of profits to WASH
Our verdict“Choose Who Gives A Crap for a higher sheet count per roll in a 3-ply recycled tissue, provided its missing additive and septic details are not deal-breakers.”
Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 48 Rolls
This is the most clearly specified choice here for households with low-flow toilets, RVs, or campers: the product is identified as septic-safe for those settings. It is made from 100% recycled paper with at least 50% post-consumer fiber, avoids chlorine bleach, and has no added dyes, inks, or fragrances. Compared with Seventh Generation’s 60-roll pack, this option has fewer rolls and just 240 sheets per roll, so it is less suited to shoppers trying to maximize total sheet supply. Its advantage is the explicit compatibility information, plus FSC and Leaping Bunny certifications. The tradeoff is that it remains a 2-ply tissue, unlike the thicker 3-ply Aria and Who Gives A Crap options, and its roll sheet count is the lowest among the products in this group.
Pros:- Made from 100% recycled paper with at least 50% post-consumer fiber
- Specified as septic-safe for standard bathrooms, low-flow toilets, RVs, and campers
- No added dyes, inks, or fragrances; whitened without chlorine bleach
- FSC-certified and Leaping Bunny-certified
Cons:- 240 sheets per roll is fewer than the other listed products
- Two-ply construction may feel less substantial than Aria or Who Gives A Crap
- The 48-roll pack has less total sheet capacity than Seventh Generation’s 60-roll option
Best for: RV and camper owners, or households with low-flow toilets, who want recycled tissue with stated septic compatibility.
Not ideal for: Large households focused on long intervals between restocks or buyers seeking more sheets per roll or three-ply thickness.
- Material:100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber
- Ply:2-ply
- Roll count:48 (two packs of 24)
- Sheets per roll:240
- Chlorine bleach:Not used
- Added dyes, inks, or fragrances:None
- Septic-safe:Yes; standard bathrooms, low-flow toilets, RVs, and campers
- Certifications:FSC Certified; Leaping Bunny Certified
Our verdict“Choose this pack if septic compatibility for a low-flow toilet, RV, or camper is your priority; look elsewhere for higher sheet capacity or three-ply tissue.”
Aria 100% Recycled 3-Ply Toilet Paper, 6 Rolls
Aria suits buyers who want three-ply cushioning without giving up a fully recycled-fiber claim. Its six rolls make it a more manageable trial pack than the 24-roll Aria option, while the 264 sheets per roll offer more sheets per roll than Seventh Generation’s 48-roll bath tissue. Aria also specifies no added inks, dyes, or fragrances, plus recyclable paper packaging and septic-safe, flushable use. Those choices make it a strong fit for households focused on recycled materials and reduced plastic packaging. The tradeoff is pack size: six rolls mean more frequent restocking than the bulk Seventh Generation pack, and the three-ply format may not suit buyers who prioritize minimizing paper use per flush. I’d choose it for a smaller household seeking a compact way to try recycled three-ply tissue.
Pros:- Made from 100% recycled fiber
- Three-ply construction for a more cushioned feel
- 264 sheets per roll, more than the 240 sheets in Seventh Generation’s 48-roll pack
- Recyclable paper packaging and no added inks, dyes, or fragrances
Cons:- Six rolls require more frequent replenishment than bulk packs
- Three-ply tissue may be more than buyers need if they prefer thinner paper
- The supplied product details do not specify the share of post-consumer fiber
Best for: Small households or first-time buyers who want 100% recycled, three-ply tissue in a compact pack with paper packaging.
Not ideal for: Large households and bulk buyers who want fewer restocks; the six-roll pack is much smaller than Seventh Generation’s 48-roll option.
- Material:100% recycled fiber
- Ply:3-ply
- Rolls per pack:6
- Sheets per roll:264
- Added inks, dyes, or fragrances:None
- Packaging:Recyclable paper
- Septic-safe:Yes
Our verdict“Choose Aria if you want recycled three-ply tissue in a small pack, but pick Seventh Generation’s 48-roll option for a bulk supply.”
Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 48 Rolls
For households that want a large supply of recycled tissue, this 48-roll pack is the lineup’s bulk-oriented choice. Each roll has 240 sheets, fewer than Aria’s six-roll 3-ply pack, but the larger quantity can reduce how often a household needs to replenish. Seventh Generation states that the paper is 100% recycled with at least 50% post-consumer fiber, and it is whitened without chlorine bleach or added dyes, inks, or fragrances. Its 2-ply format is also specified for septic systems, RVs, and campers, giving it broader stated use than Aria’s standard septic-safe claim. The tradeoffs are the lower sheet count per roll and the storage space a 48-roll supply takes. I’d favor it for planned bulk stocking, not for buyers with limited storage.
Pros:- Large 48-roll pack reduces the frequency of restocking
- Made from 100% recycled paper with at least 50% post-consumer fiber
- No added dyes, inks, or fragrances, and whitened without chlorine bleach
- Specified as suitable for septic systems, RVs, and campers
Cons:- At 240 sheets per roll, it has fewer sheets per roll than Aria’s six-roll option
- A 48-roll supply requires ample storage space
- Two-ply construction may feel less cushioned than Aria’s three-ply tissue
Best for: Families, shared homes, and RV owners who want a substantial supply of recycled tissue with stated septic and low-flow RV suitability.
Not ideal for: People with limited closet or bathroom storage, or shoppers who want more sheets on each roll; it has 240 sheets per roll versus Aria’s 264.
- Material:100% recycled paper; minimum 50% post-consumer fiber
- Ply:2-ply
- Rolls per pack:48 (4 packs of 12)
- Sheets per roll:240
- Scent and added ingredients:Unscented; no added dyes, inks, or fragrances
- Bleaching:Whitened without chlorine bleach
- Suitable for:Septic systems, RVs, campers, and standard toilet paper holders
- Dimensions:9.2 x 8 x 13.8 inches
Our verdict“Choose Seventh Generation for bulk recycled tissue and RV or septic-system use, provided you have room to store 48 rolls.”
How We Picked
I compared the seven listings on the details that are supplied: recycled-fiber positioning, ply, stated sheet count, roll format, and pack size. Those factors affect how a product may feel, how easily buyers can estimate how long a pack will last, and whether it fits a small bathroom closet or a household that prefers to stock up. I did not infer softness, strength, dissolvability, certifications, or environmental benefits beyond the product information provided.
The ranking favors options with a useful balance of clear specifications and practical fit. Who Gives A Crap ranks first because its sheet count supports a more meaningful roll comparison; Aria’s 3-ply options follow for buyers prioritizing thickness, with the six-roll pack serving a different, lower-commitment need. Seventh Generation’s larger packs rank well for restocking, but roll count alone does not establish value without comparable sheet counts. The duplicate Seventh Generation 48-roll listing is not counted as a separate advantage.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Recycled Toilet Paper
Choosing recycled tissue is not only a question of recycled content. I would match the paper’s format to household habits, storage, and comfort preferences, then compare pack details carefully so a large roll count does not disguise a smaller sheet supply.
Compare Sheets Per Roll, Not Just Roll Count
A pack with more rolls does not automatically last longer than a smaller pack. Roll sizes and sheet counts can differ, so look for both figures before comparing how often you may need to reorder. The 330-sheet specification on Who Gives A Crap makes that listing easier to assess against products that provide only a roll count in the supplied details. If sheet count is missing, treat longevity as uncertain rather than assuming every roll is equivalent. This matters especially for busy households, where a misleading roll-count comparison can lead to frequent restocking.
Choose Ply for Feel, Not as a Stand-In for Quality
Ply describes the number of paper layers, but it does not independently prove softness, strength, or how much tissue a household will use. The 3-ply Aria options are the clearest match for shoppers who want a thicker-feeling format, while the 2-ply choices may suit buyers who prefer a familiar, simpler sheet. More layers can change the feel and use pattern, so judge the format by personal preference rather than assuming higher ply is always better. If you are unsure, a smaller pack can limit commitment while you decide. That is a practical reason to distinguish Aria’s six-roll pack from its 24-roll version.
Match Pack Size to Storage and Restocking Habits
Large packs can reduce how often you shop, but they need somewhere dry and accessible to live. Count available closet or cabinet space before choosing a 48- or 60-roll supply, especially if you share a small bathroom or live in an apartment. A 24-roll pack can be a more manageable middle ground, while a six-roll pack is easier to store and better suited to trying a new format. Avoid equating bulk with savings unless the sheet count and package details allow a fair comparison. The right pack is the one your household can store and use comfortably.
Check Recycled-Content Claims Separately From Other Environmental Claims
A label describing a product as 100% recycled speaks to its stated fiber content, not every part of its environmental footprint. It does not, by itself, explain packaging materials, manufacturing impacts, or whether the product carries a particular certification. If those details matter to your purchase, check the package or manufacturer information for the specific claim you care about. Avoid assuming that two products described as 100% recycled have identical sourcing or production practices. This keeps the comparison grounded in what is actually stated rather than broad assumptions.
Use a Small Pack to Test Household Acceptance
Texture preferences vary, and one person’s preferred thickness may not work for everyone in a shared home. A smaller pack can help you judge whether the sheet’s feel and everyday use suit your household before you commit to a larger supply. Aria’s six-roll pack is the clearest low-commitment option among these listings, while larger packs make more sense once a format is familiar. If several people share the bathroom, ask whether softness, thickness, or fewer restocking trips matters most to them. A short trial can prevent a bulky pack from sitting unused.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which option is easiest to compare for how long each roll may last?
Who Gives A Crap provides a stated 330 sheets per roll, which gives you a more useful starting point than roll count alone. The other listing details here do not consistently provide sheet counts, so their total supply is harder to compare on paper. Even a sheet count cannot predict exactly how long a roll will last, since household use varies. If longevity is your priority, compare total sheets per pack wherever that information is available, not just the number of rolls.
Should I choose 3-ply recycled toilet paper over 2-ply?
Choose 3-ply if you prefer a thicker sheet and want that format to be a priority; the Aria options are the 3-ply picks in this lineup. A 2-ply product may be a better fit if you prefer a simpler format or are shopping among the larger Seventh Generation packs. Ply alone does not tell you how soft or strong a tissue will feel, and it does not show how many sheets you will use. When the difference matters to you, trying a smaller pack is a lower-commitment way to decide.
Is a 60-roll pack a better buy than a 24-roll pack?
Not automatically: the 60-roll Seventh Generation pack supplies more rolls, but the available listing details do not provide enough matching sheet-count information to compare total paper directly with every 24-roll option. A bigger pack may suit a household with storage space and predictable use, while a smaller pack can be easier to store or try. Check total sheets, package dimensions, and your actual restocking habits before choosing. If those details are unavailable, treat the longer-lasting claim as uncertain.
Are the two Seventh Generation 48-roll listings different products?
The supplied product names and pack details are the same: both are Seventh Generation 100% Recycled 2-Ply Bath Tissue, 48 rolls. There is no information here that establishes a difference in sheet count, packaging, or formulation. I would treat them as duplicate listings unless the seller’s product page or package shows a specific variation. Compare the exact item details before ordering so you do not mistake a repeated listing for a distinct option.
What should I check if recycled content is only one part of my buying decision?
Look for the exact product claims that matter to you, such as packaging information, sourcing details, or a named certification, rather than assuming recycled content answers every environmental question. The listings in this roundup identify the products as 100% recycled, but that alone does not establish details about manufacturing or packaging. Check the package or manufacturer materials for evidence of any additional claim you rely on. Comparing specific, stated details is more useful than treating all recycled products as identical.
Conclusion
For the best overall balance of comparable roll information, I recommend Who Gives A Crap, whose stated 330 sheets per roll make the supply easier to judge. Choose Aria 100% Recycled 3-Ply as the premium-feel pick if thickness matters most, and consider its six-roll pack as the best option for beginners who want to try that format with less commitment. For bulk restocking, Seventh Generation’s 60-roll pack is the standout, provided you have room and verify sheet details before comparing value. The Aria 24-roll pack fits buyers already set on 3-ply, while the 24-roll 365 by Whole Foods Market option gives shoppers another recycled-paper format to compare. My final advice: prioritize sheet count for supply planning, ply for feel, and pack size for storage—then choose the product whose stated details match your household’s main need.
NFL season / tailgating Picks
team gear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
