Round toilets exist for one reason: saving space. With a round-front bowl measuring roughly 25–28 inches deep versus the 28–31 inches of elongated models, they free up precious inches in powder rooms, apartments, and narrow bathrooms. My top pick, the TOTO Drake Round with TORNADO FLUSH and CEFIONTECT, earns the best overall spot thanks to its proven flushing power and ceramic glazing that resists skid marks — a rare combination in the round-bowl category. For tighter budgets, the Garvee 15-Inch Round Front Two-Piece delivers a complete package with a soft-close seat at a fraction of the price, while the DeerValley Compact One-Piece Skirted wins on cleanability and modern looks. The main tradeoff you’ll face is between comfort height and true space savings, and between one-piece convenience and two-piece affordability. Read on for the full breakdown of all 14 models.
Get home appliances delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Round bowls save 2–4 inches of depth versus elongated bowls, but models with 17-inch ADA chair heights often give some of that savings back — the shortest-depth picks were actually standard-height two-piece units like the Garvee and Generic 15-Inch models.
- Skirted one-piece designs (DeerValley, BAYROLL, HOROW T0338W) are dramatically easier to clean but typically cost more and can complicate rough-in installation on non-standard drain placements.
- TOTO‘s CEFIONTECT glazing was the only ceramic coating treatment in the lineup with a track record long enough to trust; the budget models rely on standard glazing and demand more frequent cleaning.
- Dual flush (0.8/1.28 GPF) appeared on nine of fourteen models, making single-flush 1.28 GPF options like the TOTO Drake the outlier — better for households worried about clogging with weak partial flushes.
- Two nearly identical products on this list (the two DeerValley compacts and the Garvee/Generic 15-inch two-pieces) differ mainly in seat height and included seats — comparing specs closely prevents paying twice for the same toilet.
| round toilet | Rough-In | Seat | Type | Bowl Shape |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HOROW 17-Inch High Round Two-P | 12 inches | Soft-close PP seat | Two-piece toilet | Round |
| Casta Diva Compact One-Piece D | 12 inches | — | — | — |
| DeerValley Compact One-Piece D | 12 inches | Soft-close PP seat (28dB) | — | — |
| DeerValley Compact One-Piece D | 12 inches | Soft-close PP | — | Round |
| 15 Inch Round Front Two-Piece | 12 inches | — | — | — |
| BAYROLL One-Piece Round Toilet | 12 inches | — | One-piece, fully skirted, round bowl | — |
| TOTO Drake Two-Piece Round 1.2 | 12 inches | — | — | — |
| Gerber Maxwell Select Round Tw | — | Included, soft-close | Two-piece toilet | Round |
| HOROW T0338W One-Piece Toilet | — | Elongated, soft-close PP | — | Elongated (compact) |
| BAYROLL One-Piece Dual Flush T | 12 inches | — | One-piece skirted, round bowl | — |
| Garvee 15" Height Round Front | 12 inches | Soft close, quick-release | Two-piece toilet | — |
| EliteEdge Two-Piece Round Toil | 12 inches | Plastic, soft-close with under-locking lid | Two-piece toilet | Round |
| Gerber Maxwell Crest Round Two | — | Soft-close, included | Two-piece toilet | Round |
| Compact Two-Piece Round Front | 12 inches | Soft-close, included | — | Round front, 15 inches |
More Details on Our Top Picks
HOROW 17-Inch High Round Two-Piece Toilet with ADA Chair Height, Dual Flush (HR-R17D)
This option stands out for combining ADA chair-height seating with a genuinely strong 360° siphon flush rated MAP 1000g, a pairing that most budget round toilets force you to choose between. The 17-inch bowl height makes a real difference for taller users and anyone with knee or hip issues — something none of the compact one-piece picks in this roundup, like the Casta Diva at 16.25 inches, can match. The 1.1/1.6 GPF dual flush also keeps water use in check without sacrificing solid-waste performance. Compared with the DeerValley skirted models, the two-piece construction trades away easy cleaning for a lower, more accessible profile and a tougher flush. The tradeoff is real, though: the seam between tank and bowl collects grime, and the round bowl gives up seating room versus elongated alternatives.
Pros:- ADA-compliant 17-inch comfort height reduces knee and back strain
- MAP 1000g siphon flush resists clogging even at low water volumes
- Dual flush saves up to 16,500 gallons per year
- Complete installation kit makes DIY setup realistic with a standard 12-inch rough-in
Cons:- Two-piece tank-to-bowl seam creates crevices that trap dirt
- Round bowl offers less seating surface than elongated models
Best for: Seniors, taller adults, and anyone with mobility limits who still wants a compact round bowl
Not ideal for: Buyers prioritizing low-maintenance cleaning — a skirted one-piece like the DeerValley wipes down far faster
- Brand:HOROW
- Model:HR-R17D
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Bowl Height:17 inches (ADA chair height)
- Bowl Shape:Round
- Flush:1.1/1.6 GPF dual flush, 360° siphon, MAP 1000g
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Seat:Soft-close PP seat
- Warranty:1-year limited; lifetime after-sales service
Our verdict“If accessibility is your top priority in a round toilet, this is the most complete package here — just expect to spend a little longer scrubbing the two-piece seams.”
Casta Diva Compact One-Piece Dual Flush Toilet, 0.8/1.28 GPF
Where the HOROW HR-R17D prioritizes seating height, this model goes all-in on footprint and water efficiency. Its 0.8/1.28 GPF dual flush is the stingiest in this batch — WaterSense certified — and still carries the same MAP 1000g clog resistance as taller rivals, so you’re not trading flush strength for conservation. The one-piece shell means no tank seam to scrub, and the quick-release soft-close seat pops off for cleaning in seconds, an advantage over the fixed-seat feel of the 15-inch two-piece compact later in this list. At 16.25 inches, the seat sits at a middle height — higher than the DeerValley’s standard height, but short of true ADA comfort. The one-year warranty is also thinner coverage than HOROW’s lifetime after-sales support.
Pros:- Compact 24.5-inch depth fits tight bathroom layouts
- MAP 1000g siphon flush prevents clogs despite low water use
- WaterSense-certified 0.8 GPF light flush is among the most efficient available
- Quick-release soft-close seat simplifies cleaning
Cons:- Round bowl is less comfortable for extended seating than elongated designs
- Only a 1-year limited warranty
Best for: Owners of small bathrooms who want maximum water savings with one-piece cleaning convenience
Not ideal for: Households with taller users or seniors — the 16.25-inch seat height falls short of ADA comfort height
- Depth:24.5 inches
- Seat Height:16.25 inches
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Flush Type:Dual flush siphon jet
- Flush Volume:0.8 / 1.28 GPF
- Design:One-piece
- Certifications:WaterSense, CUPC
- Warranty:1-year limited; lifetime technical support
Our verdict“This pick makes the most sense for small-bathroom buyers who refuse to give up flush power or water savings to save space.”
DeerValley Compact One-Piece Dual Flush Toilet, Standard Seat Height, 12″ Rough-In, Skirted Design
The headline here is the skirted base, which hides the trapway and turns what’s usually the grimiest part of a toilet into a flat, wipeable surface. That’s a genuine edge over the HOROW HR-R17D and the 15-inch two-piece compact, both of which expose the trapway and add a tank seam on top of it. Like the Casta Diva, it keeps a tight 24.5-inch depth, but it goes further with side-access panels and a pre-assembled valve, which cuts installation friction for anyone working solo. The 28dB soft-close seat is the quietest mechanism in this batch. Two caveats temper the appeal: the 250 lb weight capacity is noticeably lower than most competitors, and the standard seat height won’t suit taller or mobility-limited users the way the HOROW’s 17-inch bowl does.
Pros:- Skirted design eliminates exposed trapway curves for fast cleaning
- Compact footprint suits small bathrooms and powder rooms
- Dual flush saves up to 16,500 gallons annually versus old 3.5 GPF models
- Whisper-quiet 28dB soft-close seat and quick installation with included tools
Cons:- 250 lb weight capacity is lower than most competitors
- Standard seat height is less comfortable for tall users than comfort-height models
Best for: Cleanliness-focused buyers and guest baths where a wipe-clean skirted base matters most
Not ideal for: Heavier household members — the 250 lb rating is below what typical toilets support
- Dimensions:24.5″L × 13.375″W × 28.375″H
- Flush Type:Dual flush 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Design:One-piece, skirted
- Seat:Soft-close PP seat (28dB)
- Weight Capacity:250 lbs
- Water Savings:Up to 16,500 gallons/year vs 3.5 GPF models
- Warranty:12 months
Our verdict“Choose this one if a low-effort cleaning routine outranks seat height and weight capacity on your list.”
DeerValley Compact One-Piece Dual-Flush Toilet
This model is better suited to buyers who want a no-fuss, straightforward install rather than the strongest specs on paper. The pre-assembled valve, wax ring, bolts, and included wrench mean the box contains essentially everything a first-time installer needs — a small but meaningful convenience compared with the Casta Diva, which assumes more of your own supplies. It shares the same 24.5-inch skirted footprint and 1.1/1.6 GPF dual flush as its DeerValley sibling, so cleaning and water use are comparable; the difference comes down to details, and here the quieter 28dB seat and side-access panels of the sibling model are absent. The 250 lb weight cap also carries over, which is the main reason to step up to the HOROW HR-R17D if durability for larger users matters. It’s a solid, simple choice rather than an exciting one.
Pros:- Compact skirted one-piece fits small bathrooms
- Dual-flush system provides two water-use levels
- Installation kit includes wrench, wax ring, bolts, and pre-assembled valve
- Soft-close seat included rather than sold separately
Cons:- Round bowl provides less seating space than elongated alternatives
- Warranty coverage limited to 12 months
Best for: DIY first-timers who want every install component in the box and don’t need premium features
Not ideal for: Buyers comparing spec sheets — the sibling DeerValley offers the quiet seat and easier service access for similar space savings
- Dimensions:24.5 × 13.375 × 28.375 in
- Bowl Shape:Round
- Flush System:Dual flush, 1.1/1.6 GPF
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Seat:Soft-close PP
- Maximum User Weight:250 lbs
- Warranty:12 months
- Included Accessories:Pre-assembled valve, wax ring, bolts, wrench, manual
Our verdict“A sensible pick when installation simplicity and included hardware are your deciding factors, as long as the 250 lb capacity isn’t a dealbreaker.”
15 Inch Round Front Two-Piece Compact Toilet for Small Bathrooms, White Ceramic, 1.28 GPF Siphonic Flush, Soft Close Seat, cUPC Certified, 12 Inch Rough-In
When every inch counts, this 15-inch round front bowl claims the smallest footprint in this batch — tighter even than the 24.5-inch-depth Casta Diva and DeerValley one-pieces. That makes it a natural fit for powder rooms, basement half-baths, and remodels where the door swing barely clears the fixture. Unlike the dual-flush competitors, it uses a single 1.28 GPF siphonic flush, which is simpler to operate for guests but gives up the lighter 0.8–1.1 GPF option the Casta Diva offers for liquid waste. The side-mounted flush handle is worth checking against your layout — in a corner install it can end up against a wall. And as a two-piece, it reintroduces the tank seam the skirted DeerValley models eliminate, so cleaning takes more effort.
Pros:- Smallest bowl footprint in this batch frees up floor space
- 1.28 GPF siphonic flush balances water savings with dependable performance
- Soft-close seat included, preventing slamming in tight quarters
- Complete hardware kit and standard 12-inch rough-in simplify installation
Cons:- Two-piece construction has crevices that are harder to clean than one-piece models
- Side flush handle placement may conflict with corner or wall-adjacent installs
Best for: Powder rooms and micro-bathrooms where a 15-inch bowl is the only thing that fits
Not ideal for: Primary bathrooms in family homes — the minimal bowl size and two-piece cleaning burden wear thin with daily use
- Bowl Size:15-inch round front
- Structure:Two-piece
- Material:White ceramic, glossy glazed
- Flush Type:Siphonic jet, side-mounted handle
- Water Usage:1.28 GPF
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Certification:cUPC
- Included Accessories:Soft-close seat, wax ring, installation hardware
Our verdict“Buy this only when space is the binding constraint — larger bathrooms are better served by the one-piece picks above.”
BAYROLL One-Piece Round Toilet with Gold Flush Button
Most round toilets in this roundup are strictly functional, but this BAYROLL model makes a design argument with its gold-plated top flush button and fully skirted ceramic body. Compared with the similar BAYROLL SH-S001 reviewed below, it offers the same footprint and dual-flush mechanics (0.9/1.28 GPF) while leaning harder into a luxury-modern look for guest baths or powder rooms. The 17-inch ADA chair height and quick-release soft-close seat translate to easier daily use and faster cleaning. The tradeoff is installation friction: the water supply pipe and floor flange are not included, and the angle valve must sit exactly where BAYROLL specifies, so a plumber visit is often unavoidable.
Pros:- Dual flush at 0.9/1.28 GPF keeps water bills down
- Fully skirted base wipes clean in seconds compared with standard two-piece traps
- Gold flush button gives the bathroom a designer finish
- ADA-compliant 17-inch seat height reduces strain
Cons:- Water supply pipe and floor flange sold separately, adding hidden cost
- Angle-valve placement must meet stated clearance requirements or the skirt won’t fit
Best for: Homeowners designing a statement powder room who want a compact toilet that doubles as a visual accent
Not ideal for: Budget DIYers — missing supply components and strict angle-valve clearance rules make self-installation risky
- Brand:BAYROLL
- Model:SH-S001
- Type:One-piece, fully skirted, round bowl
- Seat Height:17 inches (ADA chair height)
- Flush:Dual flush, 0.9 / 1.28 GPF
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Dimensions:25.5 × 14.7 × 27 inches
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Buy this if you want your small bathroom’s toilet to be noticed, not just used — as long as you budget for professional installation.”
TOTO Drake Two-Piece Round 1.28 GPF Universal Height TORNADO FLUSH Toilet with CEFIONTECT, Cotton White
The TOTO Drake earns the top spot because its engineering is aimed at the problems that actually frustrate toilet owners: streaking, clogs, and repeat flushes. TORNADO FLUSH uses dual nozzles to swirl water centrifugally around the whole bowl, and the CEFIONTECT glaze is slick enough that waste slides off instead of sticking — meaning fewer scrubbing sessions and less chemical cleaner. Against the Gerber Maxwell Select, the Drake’s WaterSense-certified 1.28 GPF is proven rather than merely claimed, though both are two-piece designs with a seam to clean. The catch: a seat, wax ring, bolts, and supply lines are all extra purchases, so factor that into the total cost.
Pros:- TORNADO FLUSH rinses the entire bowl for one-flush performance
- CEFIONTECT glaze cuts cleaning frequency and chemical use
- Universal Height is ADA compliant and comfortable for most adults
- Round bowl saves space in tight bathrooms
Cons:- Seat, wax ring, mounting bolts, and supply lines sold separately
- Two-piece construction leaves a tank-to-bowl seam that’s harder to clean than one-piece rivals like the BAYROLL
Best for: Buyers who prioritize long-term dependability and low-maintenance bowl cleanliness over a bargain price
Not ideal for: Anyone wanting a complete out-of-the-box install — the separate seat and mounting parts add cost and a second shopping trip
- Brand:TOTO
- Model:CST775CEFRG#01
- Configuration:Two-piece, round bowl
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF (WaterSense certified)
- Flush System:TORNADO FLUSH with dual nozzles
- Height:Universal Height (ADA compliant)
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Certifications:EPA WaterSense, CEC, CALGreen
Our verdict“This is the pick for buyers who would rather pay a little more upfront for a toilet they rarely think about again.”
Gerber Maxwell Select Round Two-Piece Dual-Flush Toilet, White
The Gerber Maxwell Select sits in a smart middle position: unlike the TOTO Drake, it includes a soft-close seat in the box, and its canister flush valve drops fully open rather than tilting like a traditional flapper, delivering a stronger, more complete bowl clear. The smooth glazed trapway is the clog-prevention feature that matters most for families with kids or heavy use. Its 1.0/1.28 GPF dual flush matches the water savings of pricier one-piece options without the skirted-design installation headaches. The honest drawback is missing documentation — Gerber publishes no dimensions or rough-in details here, so measure your bathroom and confirm compatibility before ordering.
Pros:- Canister flush valve delivers stronger, more complete flushes than flapper systems
- Glazed trapway is engineered to resist clogs
- Soft-close seat included, unlike the TOTO Drake
- Dual 1.0/1.28 GPF options reduce water consumption
Cons:- No dimensions or installation requirements published, creating fit uncertainty
- Real-world track record is unverified with limited market history
- Two-piece design has more crevices to clean than skirted models
Best for: Households with children or heavy daily use who want strong clog resistance and an included seat at a midrange price
Not ideal for: Buyers with unusual bathroom layouts — the absence of published dimensions makes fit verification difficult
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Bowl Shape:Round
- Flush:Dual flush, 1.28 / 1.0 GPF
- Flush Valve:Canister
- Trapway:Smooth glazed
- Seat:Included, soft-close
- Color:White
Our verdict“A sensible midrange choice for clog-prone households, provided you confirm the fit before buying.”
HOROW T0338W One-Piece Toilet with ADA Chair Height and Dual Flush
Full disclosure for a roundup about round bowls: the HOROW T0338W actually has an elongated bowl, yet it still belongs here because it occupies nearly the same footprint (26.6 × 15 × 26 inches) as true compact rounds like the BAYROLL SH-S001 — you effectively get elongated comfort in round-bowl space. Its 17.3-inch seat height edges out most rivals, and the 10-inch or 12-inch rough-in options mean it fits older homes where a 12-inch-only model like the Gerber won’t. The 1.6 GPF solid flush is less water-efficient than the 1.28 GPF class leaders, and the one-year warranty is thin compared with major brands.
Pros:- Available in 10-inch or 12-inch rough-in for older plumbing layouts
- 17.3-inch chair-height seat is among the tallest here
- Compact 26.6-inch depth fits spaces meant for round bowls
- Fully glazed 2-inch trapway aids waste removal
Cons:- Elongated bowl means it isn’t a true round toilet despite similar dimensions
- 1.6 GPF solid flush lags the water efficiency of WaterSense-class rivals
- Only a one-year warranty
Best for: Buyers in older homes with a 10-inch rough-in who want maximum seat comfort in minimal floor space
Not ideal for: Water-saving purists — the 1.6 GPF solid flush uses more water than the 1.28 GPF alternatives in this lineup
- Dimensions:26.6 × 15 × 26 inches
- Seat Height:17.3 inches (ADA chair height)
- Bowl Shape:Elongated (compact)
- Flush Type:Dual flush, siphon
- Flush Volume:1.1 / 1.6 GPF
- Trapway:2 inches, fully glazed
- Rough-In Options:10 or 12 inches
- Seat:Elongated, soft-close PP
Our verdict“If your bathroom has a 10-inch rough-in and you still want a comfortable chair-height seat, this is the workaround pick.”
BAYROLL One-Piece Dual Flush Toilet, 17″ ADA Chair Height, Compact Skirted Round Bowl with Soft Close Seat
This BAYROLL SH-S001 is the practical sibling of the gold-button model earlier in this lineup — identical body, identical 0.9/1.28 GPF dual flush, but with a standard finish that suits everyday bathrooms, apartments, and even light commercial use. Its standout spec is the MAP 1000g siphon rating, meaning it clears a full kilogram of solid waste in a single flush — a claim most budget compacts can’t make. The quick-release soft-close seat pops off for cleaning in seconds, a real advantage over the two-piece Gerber Maxwell Select. Plan for the same install hurdles as its sibling: check angle-valve compatibility first, source the missing supply pipe and floor flange, and consider a pro.
Pros:- MAP 1000g flush rating clears heavy loads in one flush
- Compact 25.5-inch depth suits tight bathrooms and commercial spaces
- Skirted one-piece body is the easiest-to-clean style in this roundup
- Quick-release soft-close seat speeds up deep cleaning
Cons:- Angle-valve compatibility must be verified before purchase
- Water supply pipe and floor flange excluded, and professional installation is often needed
- Fragile ceramic construction carries shipping damage risk
Best for: Apartment owners and small-bathroom renovators who want one-piece easy cleaning with proven flush power
Not ideal for: Rural or fragile-delivery-averse buyers — ceramic shipping damage risk and no included floor flange complicate DIY installs
- Brand:BAYROLL
- Model:SH-S001
- Type:One-piece skirted, round bowl
- Seat Height:17 inches (ADA chair height)
- Flush:Dual flush siphon, 0.9 / 1.28 GPF (MAP 1000g)
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Dimensions:25.5″ D × 14.7″ W × 27″ H
- Material:Ceramic
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“The best pure small-space performer here — choose it over its gold-button twin when durability matters more than décor.”
Garvee 15″ Height Round Front Two-Piece Space-Saving Toilet
This Garvee model stands out for one reason above all: a 17-inch depth that shaves inches off the footprint of a typical round bowl. Where the Gerber Maxwell Crest or EliteEdge demand more floor space, this unit fits bathrooms where every inch between the door swing and the vanity counts. The 1.28 GPF siphonic flush with a glazed trapway keeps performance respectable despite the small size, and the quick-release soft-close seat makes cleaning around a two-piece design less of a chore. The tradeoff is the 15-inch seat height — noticeably lower than the ADA-compliant 17.5 inches on the EliteEdge — which taller users and anyone with mobility concerns will feel on every sit-down. Compared with the compact one-piece options like the DeerValley, it also lacks a skirted base, so cleaning under the bowl takes more effort.
Pros:- Extremely shallow 17-inch depth for genuinely tight floor plans
- Water-efficient 1.28 GPF siphonic flush with glazed trapway
- Quick-release soft-close seat simplifies cleaning
- cUPC-certified stain-resistant glaze resists discoloration
Cons:- 15-inch seat height is far below modern comfort-height standards
- Unskirted two-piece base has crevices that collect grime
- At 95.4 pounds, moving and installing it alone is difficult
Best for: Homeowners with powder rooms or narrow half-baths where a standard-depth toilet physically won’t fit
Not ideal for: Taller adults or anyone with knee or mobility issues — the 15-inch seat height sits well below comfort height
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Seat Height:15 inches
- Depth:17 inches (space-saving design)
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Flush:1.28 GPF siphonic, side handle
- Seat:Soft close, quick-release
- Certification:cUPC certified
- Weight:95.4 lbs
Our verdict“Buy this only if depth is your limiting dimension — the shallow footprint is the whole point, and the low seat height is the price you pay.”
EliteEdge Two-Piece Round Toilet, ADA Comfort Height
The EliteEdge earns its spot by pairing a round bowl with a 17.5-inch ADA-compliant seat height — a combination most compact toilets skip. The Garvee and the Compact 15-inch model both sit at 15 inches, which is rough on aging knees; this one stands taller while keeping the round-front footprint modest. The 1.28 GPF flush matches the rest of the lineup for water efficiency, and the soft-close seat with an under-locking lid is a small but genuine safety touch for households with kids who slam lids. The tradeoffs are subtler but real: a plastic seat feels less premium than what Gerber or TOTO include, and the two-piece ceramic build at 92.9 pounds means installation is a two-person job. If accessibility matters more than a skirted base or dual-flush options, this pick makes the most sense.
Pros:- ADA-compliant 17.5-inch seat height eases sitting and standing
- Round bowl keeps the footprint compact despite the taller frame
- Water-efficient 1.28 GPF flush
- Soft-close seat with under-locking lid for safety
Cons:- Plastic seat feels less durable than premium alternatives
- Unskirted two-piece design makes thorough cleaning slower
- Heavy at 92.9 pounds with no tool-free installation kit
Best for: Older adults or buyers with mobility concerns who want an accessible seat height without paying premium-brand prices
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a skirted base or dual-flush control — the basic plastic seat and single flush feel dated next to one-piece competitors
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Bowl Shape:Round
- Seat Height:17.5 inches (ADA compliant)
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Material:Ceramic
- Seat:Plastic, soft-close with under-locking lid
- Weight:92.9 lbs
Our verdict“The most accessible round bowl in this batch for the money — choose it when seat height outranks every other feature.”
Gerber Maxwell Crest Round Two-Piece Toilet with Soft-Close Seat
What separates the Gerber Maxwell Crest is what’s in the box. While most competitors ship a bowl and tank and leave you scavenging for a wax ring at the hardware store, this one includes the wax ring, mounting hardware, and a tool-free installation kit alongside the soft-close seat — genuinely useful for a DIY replacement. The glazed trapway is engineered to resist clogs, and Gerber’s commercial-line reputation gives the 1.28 GPF flush more credibility than no-name imports. Compared with the EliteEdge, you get a comparable brand-backed build and similar water efficiency, though Gerber doesn’t specify a comfort-height seat here, so taller buyers should verify measurements before ordering. The honest drawback: this is still a basic unskirted two-piece, so it cleans harder than the DeerValley skirted one-piece models, and there’s no dual-flush option like the Gerber Maxwell Select sibling offers.
Pros:- Wax ring, hardware, and tool-free installation kit included
- Glazed trapway designed to resist clogging
- Recognized plumbing brand with commercial-line heritage
- Soft-close seat bundled at no extra cost
Cons:- No dual-flush option — single 1.28 GPF flush only
- Unskirted two-piece base is harder to keep clean than skirted models
- Seat height not clearly specified as comfort height, unlike the EliteEdge
Best for: DIY installers and landlords who want everything needed for a drop-in replacement in one purchase
Not ideal for: Buyers wanting dual-flush water savings or a skirted base — the Maxwell Select or a one-piece model serves both needs better
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Bowl Shape:Round
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Trapway:Glazed
- Seat:Soft-close, included
- ADA Compliant:Yes
- Included Components:Bowl, tank with cover, soft-close seat, installation hardware, wax ring
Our verdict“The most install-ready round toilet here — ideal when you want to finish the job in one trip and trust the brand behind the flush.”
Compact Two-Piece Round Front Toilet, 1.28 GPF, White
This unbranded compact model plays the straightforward value card: a 15-inch round-front bowl, 1.28 GPF siphonic flush, soft-close seat, and a wax ring and hardware included — the essentials, nothing wasted. It overlaps heavily with the Garvee on paper, but where that model justifies itself with an ultra-shallow 17-inch depth, this one is a more conventional compact footprint for standard small bathrooms rather than truly cramped ones. The cUPC certification and glazed ceramic surface mean it isn’t a gamble on unverified plumbing parts, which matters at this end of the market. The compromises are predictable: the round-front bowl offers noticeably less seating surface than an elongated bowl, the 15-inch height will be too low for comfort-height buyers (the EliteEdge solves that), and it’s locked to a 12-inch rough-in with no flexibility. As a basement or guest-bath workhorse, though, it gets the job done.
Pros:- Soft-close seat and full installation accessories included
- 1.28 GPF siphonic flush keeps water bills in check
- cUPC-certified glazed ceramic for stain resistance
- Compact footprint suits standard small bathrooms
Cons:- Round-front bowl provides less seating comfort than elongated options
- Requires exactly a 12-inch rough-in with no adapter flexibility
- Side-mounted flush handle placement may not suit every layout
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers outfitting a guest bath, basement half-bath, or rental unit where function beats features
Not ideal for: Primary bathrooms used daily by taller adults — the low seat and small round bowl get tiring fast
- Bowl Shape:Round front, 15 inches
- Configuration:Two-piece
- Flush Type:Siphonic, side-mounted handle
- Water Consumption:1.28 GPF
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Seat:Soft-close, included
- Certification:cUPC
- Included Accessories:Wax ring and installation hardware
Our verdict“A sensible, no-frills round toilet for spare bathrooms — skip it if this throne will see daily duty.”
How We Picked
I evaluated each toilet against five criteria that matter most to round-toilet buyers. Depth and footprint came first, since space savings are the entire point of a round bowl. Flush performance came second — I favored models with fully glazed trapways, siphonic or tornado-style flushing, and WaterSense-certified 1.28 GPF (or dual-flush) ratings over vague or unlisted specs. Bowl height was weighted carefully: 17-inch chair-height bowls suit older buyers and bad knees, but they raise the overall profile in rooms where every inch counts.
From there I judged build and finish quality — ceramic weight, glazing quality, whether the seat was included, and certification marks like cUPC and ADA compliance — and finally installation and maintenance, where skirted one-piece designs scored well for cleaning but lost points for harder retrofits. Products ranked higher when they solved the round-toilet buyer’s core problem (fitting a small space) without sacrificing flushing reliability. That’s why the TOTO Drake leads despite a higher price, and why budget two-piece models still earned spots for buyers who prioritize depth savings above all else.
| round toilet | Type | Bowl Shape |
|---|---|---|
| HOROW 17-Inch High Round Two-P | Two-piece toilet | Round |
| Casta Diva Compact One-Piece D | — | — |
| DeerValley Compact One-Piece D | — | — |
| DeerValley Compact One-Piece D | — | Round |
| 15 Inch Round Front Two-Piece | — | — |
| BAYROLL One-Piece Round Toilet | One-piece, fully skirted, round bowl | — |
| TOTO Drake Two-Piece Round 1.2 | — | — |
| Gerber Maxwell Select Round Tw | Two-piece toilet | Round |
| HOROW T0338W One-Piece Toilet | — | Elongated (compact) |
| BAYROLL One-Piece Dual Flush T | One-piece skirted, round bowl | — |
| Garvee 15" Height Round Front | Two-piece toilet | — |
| EliteEdge Two-Piece Round Toil | Two-piece toilet | Round |
| Gerber Maxwell Crest Round Two | Two-piece toilet | Round |
| Compact Two-Piece Round Front | — | Round front, 15 inches |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Round Toilets
Choosing a round toilet involves more than measuring your floor. These are the factors that separate a satisfying purchase from a return shipment, and most of them get decided before you ever compare models.Measure Your Rough-In Before Anything Else
The single most common round-toilet mistake is ordering before measuring the rough-in distance — the span from the finished wall to the center of the drain bolts. Nearly every toilet on this list requires a 12-inch rough-in, which covers most homes built after the 1930s, but older houses often have 10-inch or 14-inch drains that demand special-order models. A mismatch of even half an inch can leave a gap behind the tank or make installation impossible without an offset flange, which itself reduces flush performance. Measure to the bolts holding your current toilet down, not to the wall behind the tank, since baseboards and trim distort the measurement. Also verify the width clearance around the bowl: round bowls save depth, not width, and you still want at least 15 inches from the bowl centerline to any sidewall or vanity for code-compliant, comfortable use.
Chair Height vs. Standard Height: The Comfort Tradeoff
Standard bowls sit around 15 inches high; chair-height (comfort or ADA-height) bowls sit at 17–19 inches. Chair height is far easier on knees and hips and is often required for aging-in-place plans, which explains why models like the HOROW R17D and BAYROLL 17-inch lean into it. But here’s the tradeoff specific to this category: buyers shopping round bowls are usually fighting for inches, and a taller bowl with a thick seat can feel nearly as imposing as a compact elongated model. Shorter adults and children sometimes find 17-inch bowls less comfortable because their feet dangle, which affects natural function. My advice: if the bathroom serves guests of all ages and space is tight, standard height saves the profile; if the primary user is over 60 or has mobility limits, prioritize the chair height and accept the extra inch or two.
One-Piece vs. Two-Piece: Beyond the Price Tag
One-piece toilets (the DeerValley, BAYROLL, HOROW T0338W, and Casta Diva models) have no seam between tank and bowl, which means no crevice collecting grime — a genuine advantage in small bathrooms where cleaning access is awkward. They also install as a single, though heavier, unit. Two-piece models cost less, are easier to carry up stairs and through narrow doorways one section at a time, and replacement parts are universally available. The hidden cost of one-piece designs shows up years later: if the tank or bowl cracks, you replace the whole unit, whereas a two-piece lets you swap just the damaged half. Two-piece tanks can also develop leaks at the rubber gasket between the halves, a maintenance item one-piece owners never face. Neither is objectively better — it’s a cleaning-versus-cost-and-serviceability decision.
Understanding Flush Ratings and Clog Resistance
A 1.28 GPF single flush is the reliable default — it meets WaterSense standards and delivers a full siphonic action every time. Dual-flush models (0.8/1.28 GPF) save water on liquid waste, but the reduced 0.8-gallon cycle is weaker and more prone to incomplete clearing, especially in older homes with cast-iron drain lines that carry less momentum. Trapway design matters as much as the number: fully glazed, 2-inch trapways resist waste snagging, while unglazed or 1.5-inch trapways clog more often regardless of flush volume. TOTO’s TORNADO FLUSH uses a centrifugal rinsing action rather than a single jet, which cleans the bowl walls more thoroughly and streaks less — useful if you hate scrubbing. If your household has a history of clogs, favor a proven single-flush system over an aggressive dual-flush marketing claim.
Skirted Bases and Other Cleaning Considerations
A skirted design — a smooth, flat column covering the trapway — turns a five-minute scrub of curls and crevices into a thirty-second wipe. For anyone cleaning a cramped powder room, that’s a bigger quality-of-life upgrade than most spec sheets suggest. The catch: skirted toilets can be harder to install because the mounting bolts access differently, and on uneven floors the skirt may not sit flush, leaving a visible gap. Also check whether the seat is included; several budget models on this list bundle a soft-close seat while others assume you’ll buy separately, which adds to the real cost. Soft-close seats themselves are worth having in small bathrooms, where a slammed lid echoes loudly, and they protect fingers for kids. Finally, consider seat shape compatibility — round seats are not interchangeable with elongated ones, so replacement parts must match the bowl you bought.
When to Pay More, and When a Budget Model Is Enough
Premium pricing in this category mostly buys you glazing technology, brand-backed parts availability, and flush engineering — that’s the case for TOTO’s CEFIONTECT coating, which reduces how often the bowl needs scrubbing for years, not months. If the toilet is going in a heavily used main bathroom, the extra spend pays back in maintenance time. For a guest bathroom or rental unit used a few times a week, a basic 1.28 GPF two-piece with decent glazing does the same job for far less money, and nobody will notice the difference. Mid-range one-piece compacts make sense when appearance matters — they photograph better and look intentional in renovated small baths. What I’d never skimp on: certification marks (cUPC, WaterSense, ADA where applicable), since unlisted-certification imports can fail inspection and complicate insurance claims after leaks.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much space does a round toilet actually save compared to an elongated one?
A round-front bowl typically measures 25–28 inches from the wall to the bowl front, while elongated bowls run 28–31 inches, so you save roughly 2–4 inches of walking or door-clearance space. That may sound trivial, but in a bathroom where the door swings toward the toilet or the vanity sits opposite, those inches determine whether the door opens fully or bangs against the bowl. Note that the savings apply to depth only — round and elongated bowls are about the same width. Also remember that a 17-inch chair-height round model can end up with a similar overall footprint to a standard-height elongated toilet, so if depth is your absolute constraint, pair the round bowl with a standard 15-inch height as the Garvee and Generic 15-inch models do.
Is dual flush worth it, or does a single 1.28 GPF flush make more sense?
Dual flush saves water — the 0.8-gallon liquid cycle can cut household water use meaningfully over a year — but the savings come with a reliability tradeoff. The reduced cycle has less siphonic force, so it can leave waste behind or require a second press, which erodes the water savings entirely. In older homes with cast-iron or long horizontal drain runs, plumbers often recommend single-flush 1.28 GPF because the full-volume flush moves waste farther with better momentum. If you live in a newer home with PVC drains, use the toilet lightly, and want the lowest water bill possible, dual flush is a reasonable choice — nine of the fourteen models here offer it. Households with clogging history or kids who use partial-flush buttons incorrectly should stick with a proven single flush like the TOTO Drake’s.
Can I replace my old elongated toilet with a round one without changing my plumbing?
Usually yes, as long as your rough-in matches — the distance from the wall to the closet bolts, which needs to be 12 inches for nearly every model in this roundup. Round and elongated toilets use the same standard drain flange and floor bolt spacing, so the swap is purely a matter of removing the old unit and setting the new one. Do confirm your supply line location, since some one-piece and skirted designs position the tank inlet differently and may need a new angle stop or flexible supply hose. One caution: skirted models sometimes require different floor anchors, so check the installation manual before demo day. And if you’re moving from a two-piece to a one-piece, recruit a helper — one-piece units weigh well over 90 pounds and are awkward to lower onto wax rings alone.
Are chair-height round toilets comfortable, or should I stick with standard height?
Chair height (17–19 inches, like the HOROW R17D and BAYROLL 17-inch) is genuinely easier for taller adults, seniors, and anyone with knee, hip, or back issues — the mechanics of sitting and standing improve noticeably with those extra two to four inches. The downside appears for shorter users and children, whose feet may not rest flat on the floor, which is less comfortable and less ergonomically healthy over long sits. In a guest or family bathroom serving mixed users, standard height around 15 inches is the safer all-around compromise. Chair height also matters for accessibility planning: if you’re renovating with aging in place in mind, an ADA-compliant 17-inch bowl now avoids a costly replacement later. The honest answer is that the ideal height depends on who uses the bathroom most, not on any universal standard.
Do round toilets clog more easily than elongated toilets?
The bowl shape itself doesn’t cause clogs — trapway diameter, glazing, and flush engineering do. A round bowl with a fully glazed 2-inch trapway and a strong siphonic or TORNADO flush will outperform a poorly glazed elongated model every time. Where round toilets historically got a bad reputation is in compact budget models that pair smaller trapways with weaker flush valves, so the shape took the blame. Within this lineup, the TOTO Drake’s fully glazed trapway and centrifugal rinse set the reliability benchmark, while the cheapest two-piece options are adequate but unforgiving of large loads. If clog resistance is your top concern, prioritize a fully glazed trapway and a known flush system over bowl shape, and avoid pushing partial-flush cycles for solid waste.
Conclusion
After comparing all fourteen models, the right choice comes down to which constraint dominates your bathroom. For best overall, the TOTO Drake Round with TORNADO FLUSH and CEFIONTECT stands apart — it pairs the category’s most reliable flush with a glazing finish that keeps cleaning minimal, justifying its premium over every budget option here. For best value, the Garvee 15-Inch Round Front Two-Piece bundles a soft-close seat, siphonic flush, and true space-saving depth at a price that undercuts the one-piece compacts. For best premium, the HOROW T0338W One-Piece with ADA chair height delivers skirted cleanability and modern styling in a full-featured package. For beginners and first-time installers, the Gerber Maxwell Crest with its included soft-close seat offers the simplest, most forgiving setup with widely available parts. And for specific needs: the DeerValley Compact Skirted suits style-conscious small-bath renovations, the HOROW R17D handles accessibility requirements on a budget, and the Generic 15-inch two-piece is the pick when absolute minimum depth is non-negotiable. Whatever you choose, measure your rough-in first — no flush technology fixes a toilet that doesn’t fit your drain.
Fall yard work Picks
leaf blowers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
