Choosing among Signature Hardware toilets comes down to more than appearance: bowl shape, rough-in size, ease of cleaning, and the level of built-in comfort all affect whether a model suits your bathroom. I rank the Carraway first for its chair-height elongated bowl and concealed trapway, while the Benbrook with chrome lever is my balanced pick for a skirted design with a stated long-term warranty. For hands-free bidet functions and lower flush volume, the Vela Plus offers the most features, but its weight, electrical needs, and 12-inch rough-in make it a more involved choice.
Get home appliances delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
The main tradeoffs are straightforward: round bowls save space, while elongated bowls give more room; skirted designs simplify access around the base but do not make a heavy two-piece toilet easy to install; and smart features add comfort while bringing more setup and maintenance considerations. I compare each model by how well it serves a distinct bathroom need, not by treating every extra feature as an automatic advantage.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Best balanced skirted option: The Benbrook with chrome lever pairs an elongated bowl, included seat, and 25-year limited warranty; plan for its 122.4-pound weight and two-piece assembly.
- Best for chair-height access: The Carraway has an elongated chair-height bowl and concealed trapway, with ADA requirements met when installation follows applicable guidelines.
- Best for tight floor plans: The Bradenton’s round bowl saves front-to-back space, but its specified 14-inch rough-in must match the bathroom plumbing.
- Best for smart bidet features: The Vela Plus includes heating, drying, adjustable bidet settings, and automatic functions, but weighs 170 pounds and needs a 12-inch rough-in.
- Lever finish matters less than fit: The two Benbrook versions share the key bowl and skirted design; choose chrome or brushed nickel to coordinate with existing hardware.
| signaturehardware toilet | Configuration | Bowl | Flush rate | Material |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Signature Hardware Carraway Tw | Two-piece skirted toilet | Elongated, chair-height | 1.28 GPF | Porcelain |
| Signature Hardware Benbrook Tw | Two-piece | Elongated, skirted | 1.28 GPF | Vitreous china |
| Signature Hardware Benbrook Tw | Two-piece | Elongated, skirted | 1.28 GPF | Vitreous china |
| Signature Hardware Bradenton T | Two-piece | Round | 1.28 GPF | Vitreous china |
| Signature Hardware Vela Plus O | One-piece, tankless | Elongated | 1.0 GPF | Vitreous china |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Signature Hardware Carraway Two-Piece Skirted Elongated Toilet, 1.28 GPF
The Carraway earns my top position because its feature set addresses several practical needs without relying on electronic extras: an elongated chair-height bowl, a skirted profile, and an included seat. The concealed trapway gives the exterior a cleaner outline and makes the floor around the base easier to reach than around a conventional exposed trapway. Its 1.28 GPF flush rate also gives buyers a lower-volume option than older, higher-flush toilets, though actual water savings depend on what it replaces.
Compared with the Benbrook models, the Carraway’s clearest distinction is its stated chair-height design and ADA-related positioning. It meets ADA requirements when installed according to the applicable guidelines, but buyers should confirm the full installation and bathroom clearances rather than assume the toilet alone guarantees an accessible room. The Benbrook may be the more straightforward choice if a buyer mainly wants a skirted elongated toilet and a stated 25-year limited warranty; the Carraway is more compelling when seat height is central.
There are tradeoffs. At 129 pounds, it is heavier than either Benbrook version, and its two-piece construction still requires assembly. The supplied details do not give a rough-in measurement or exact seat height, so I would verify both before ordering, especially for a replacement project. An optional bidet seat adds one inch to the bowl height, a change that could affect comfort or accessibility in a room with a carefully planned seat height. I would choose the Carraway for a comfort-focused bathroom, not for a buyer who wants the lightest or simplest installation.
Pros:- Chair-height elongated bowl supports easier sitting and standing for many users.
- Skirted concealed trapway makes the exterior and nearby floor easier to clean.
- Uses 1.28 GPF and includes a plastic seat.
- Meets ADA requirements when installed according to applicable guidelines.
Cons:- At 129 pounds, it can be difficult to move and position.
- An optional bidet seat adds one inch to bowl height, which can change fit.
- The supplied specifications do not state rough-in or exact seat height.
Best for: Buyers prioritizing an elongated chair-height bowl, a concealed trapway, and a skirted exterior.
Not ideal for: Shoppers who need a lightweight fixture, want a one-piece installation, or cannot verify rough-in and final seat height before purchase.
- Configuration:Two-piece skirted toilet
- Bowl:Elongated, chair-height
- Flush rate:1.28 GPF
- Material:Porcelain
- Installation:Floor-mounted
- Seat:Plastic seat included
- Weight:129 pounds
- Accessibility:Meets ADA requirements when installed according to guidelines
Our verdict“I rank the Carraway first for buyers who want chair-height elongated seating and a tidy skirted profile, provided they verify fit details before installation.”
Signature Hardware Benbrook Two-Piece Skirted Elongated Toilet, 1.28 GPF, White with Chrome Lever
The Benbrook with chrome lever is my pick for buyers who want the everyday practicality of a skirted elongated toilet without moving into smart-toilet complexity. Its elongated bowl, included seat, and 1.28 GPF flush rate cover the basics, while the skirted sides make the floor around the fixture more accessible for routine cleaning. The chrome lever suits bathrooms already using chrome taps or accessories, so the finish can feel coordinated rather than like a mismatched detail.
Against the Carraway, the Benbrook has a stated 25-year limited warranty and a slightly lighter listed weight, but it does not come with the Carraway’s stated chair-height feature or ADA positioning. Compared with the brushed-nickel Benbrook, its meaningful difference is the lever finish; the core configuration is very similar. That makes this version the sensible default when chrome is already part of the room, while the brushed-nickel model suits a different hardware palette.
The downside is that skirted does not mean simple to install. This is a 122.4-pound, two-piece fixture, so moving the bowl and tank into place may require help, and two-piece assembly adds steps compared with a one-piece toilet. Buyers should also confirm the rough-in and overall dimensions, which are not supplied here. I would put the Benbrook ahead of the Bradenton for comfort and cleanability, but skip it if a round bowl is necessary to preserve floor space.
Pros:- Elongated bowl offers more sitting room than a round-bowl option.
- Skirted sides improve access to the floor around the base.
- Includes an elongated plastic seat and chrome tank lever.
- Covered by a 25-year limited warranty.
Cons:- Listed weight of 122.4 pounds makes handling more demanding.
- Two-piece assembly involves more steps than a one-piece toilet.
- Rough-in and exact overall dimensions are not included in the supplied details.
Best for: Buyers seeking a skirted elongated two-piece toilet with a chrome lever, included seat, and stated 25-year limited warranty.
Not ideal for: Small bathrooms that need a round bowl, or buyers who want a one-piece unit or confirmed chair-height specification.
- Model:483979
- Configuration:Two-piece
- Bowl:Elongated, skirted
- Flush rate:1.28 GPF
- Material:Vitreous china
- Installation:Floor-mounted
- Finish:White with chrome lever
- Weight and warranty:122.4 pounds; 25-year limited warranty
Our verdict“I recommend this Benbrook as the balanced choice for buyers who want a skirted elongated design and have room for a heavy two-piece installation.”
Signature Hardware Benbrook Two-Piece Skirted Elongated Toilet, 1.28 GPF, White with Brushed Nickel Lever
This Benbrook keeps the same skirted elongated two-piece format as the chrome version and changes the tank lever to brushed nickel. That small distinction matters when a bathroom already has brushed-nickel faucets or accessories and the toilet hardware would otherwise stand out. The listed package includes an elongated plastic seat, and the 1.28 GPF flush rate makes it comparable on water use to the other standard Benbrook and Carraway models in this group.
Its strongest point of difference is the supplied listing’s ADA-compliant designation, alongside the familiar 25-year limited warranty. That makes it a more relevant Benbrook choice for buyers checking accessible-fixture specifications than the chrome version, although installation conditions and room layout still determine whether the completed bathroom meets accessibility needs. The Carraway also has stated ADA-related language and a chair-height bowl, so buyers focused specifically on seat height should compare its missing exact height details against the measurements they need.
The brushed-nickel lever does not change the installation tradeoffs: the unit weighs 122.8 pounds and its two-piece construction means more assembly than a one-piece design. It is only marginally heavier than the chrome model, so that difference should not decide the purchase; the room’s finish scheme and fit matter more. I would not pay attention to the lever finish at the expense of checking rough-in, clearance, and final seat height, none of which are fully specified in the information supplied.
Pros:- Elongated bowl and skirted base match the practical benefits of the chrome Benbrook.
- Brushed-nickel lever coordinates with matching bathroom fixtures.
- Includes an elongated plastic seat and uses 1.28 GPF.
- Listing states ADA compliance and a 25-year limited warranty.
Cons:- At 122.8 pounds, it is a heavy fixture to move.
- Two-piece construction requires assembly beyond a one-piece installation.
- The supplied information does not provide rough-in or exact seat-height measurements.
Best for: Buyers coordinating brushed-nickel bathroom hardware who also want an elongated skirted toilet and an ADA-compliant model listing.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a compact round bowl, want a one-piece toilet, or need exact accessibility dimensions before choosing.
- Model:483980
- Configuration:Two-piece
- Bowl:Elongated, skirted
- Flush rate:1.28 GPF
- Material:Vitreous china
- Finish:White with brushed-nickel lever
- Included component:Elongated plastic seat
- Weight and warranty:122.8 pounds; 25-year limited warranty
- Accessibility:Listed as ADA compliant
Our verdict“I would choose this Benbrook over the chrome version when brushed nickel and the stated ADA designation match the project, not for a change in core toilet design.”
Signature Hardware Bradenton Two-Piece Round Toilet, 1.28 GPF, 14-Inch Rough-In, White
The Bradenton takes the space-saving route with a round bowl, setting it apart from every elongated toilet in this lineup. In a compact bathroom, a shorter bowl can preserve clearance in front of the toilet or make a tight layout more workable. The floor-mounted vitreous-china, two-piece construction is familiar, and its 14-inch rough-in is a specific fit requirement buyers can check against the existing plumbing before committing.
That dimension is both a useful specification and a limitation. The Benbrook and Carraway entries do not state their rough-in in the supplied details, while the Bradenton explicitly calls for 14 inches; it is a good match only when the bathroom is built for that measurement or a qualified installer confirms a suitable solution. Compared with the elongated models, the Bradenton sacrifices some sitting room to gain a more compact bowl shape. Its 1.28 GPF rate matches the other conventional toilets here, so the deciding factor is more likely layout than water-use distinction.
The supplied product information does not give a weight, seat inclusion, or a detailed list of drawbacks, so I would confirm those points with the seller before planning transport and installation. A round bowl may feel less spacious to adults who prefer elongated seating, and two-piece construction still means tank-to-bowl assembly. I rank it below the Benbrook models for general-purpose comfort, but for a bathroom where front clearance is tight, the Bradenton’s bowl shape can be more valuable than a skirted exterior.
Pros:- Round bowl can reduce front-to-back footprint compared with elongated alternatives.
- 14-inch rough-in requirement is clearly stated for fit checking.
- Vitreous-china, floor-mounted two-piece construction.
- Covered by a 25-year limited warranty.
Cons:- Round bowl gives less sitting room than the elongated models in this comparison.
- A 14-inch rough-in limits suitability for bathrooms with other rough-in dimensions.
- Supplied details do not confirm included seat, product weight, or full dimensions.
Best for: Owners of smaller bathrooms who need a round bowl and have a verified 14-inch rough-in.
Not ideal for: Buyers who prioritize elongated-bowl comfort or whose existing plumbing uses a different rough-in measurement.
- Model:462387 Bradenton
- Configuration:Two-piece
- Bowl:Round
- Flush rate:1.28 GPF
- Rough-in:14 inches
- Material:Vitreous china
- Installation:Floor-mounted
- Warranty:25-year limited warranty
Our verdict“I recommend the Bradenton when compact bowl shape and a matching 14-inch rough-in matter more than elongated seating.”
Signature Hardware Vela Plus One-Piece Elongated Smart Toilet, 1.0 GPF
The Vela Plus is in a different category from the four conventional two-piece toilets: it is a one-piece, tankless smart toilet with a built-in bidet seat and a 1.0 GPF flush rate. Its functions include adjustable water pressure and temperature, a heated seat, air drying, an adjustable nozzle, a night light, UV sterilization, deodorizer, automatic lid, and automatic or manual flushing. Buyers who already want bidet washing and hands-free conveniences can get those features in one integrated fixture rather than fitting a separate seat to a conventional toilet.
Compared with the Carraway or Benbrook, the Vela Plus brings more day-to-day functions and a lower listed flush volume, but it is not the easy choice for a basic replacement. It weighs 170 pounds, requires a 12-inch rough-in, and its tankless design makes installation planning different from a standard two-piece toilet. The supplied information does not state electrical requirements, so I would confirm power access and installation instructions before purchase. Its 15.75-inch bowl height is also distinct from the Carraway’s chair-height description; buyers choosing for accessibility should compare exact installed measurements rather than assume the smart model offers the same seating position.
The integrated feature package also adds more components than a manual toilet, which may not suit buyers who prefer straightforward operation and fewer electronic functions. At 26.88 inches deep and 15.75 inches wide, its listed dimensions help with planning, but its overall height is 18.5 inches and the 12-inch rough-in still needs verification. I rank it fifth for general-purpose replacement because it asks more of the room and installer; for someone specifically seeking bidet comfort and automatic functions, it becomes the clear feature leader.
Pros:- Integrated bidet seat offers adjustable water pressure and temperature.
- Includes heated seating, air drying, night light, deodorizer, and UV sterilization.
- Automatic lid and automatic or manual flush options add convenience.
- Uses 1.0 GPF and has a listed 12-inch rough-in.
Cons:- At 170 pounds, it is the heaviest model in this comparison.
- Requires a 12-inch rough-in, which must match the bathroom.
- Electrical needs are not stated in the supplied specifications and should be confirmed.
Best for: Buyers who want an integrated bidet, heated seat, drying, and automatic functions in a one-piece toilet.
Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking a simple conventional replacement, a lighter fixture, or a toilet that avoids electronic setup and maintenance.
- Configuration:One-piece, tankless
- Bowl:Elongated
- Flush rate:1.0 GPF
- Rough-in:12 inches
- Dimensions:26.88 in D × 15.75 in W × 18.5 in H
- Bowl height:15.75 inches
- Material:Vitreous china
- Weight:170 pounds
- Bidet and comfort features:Adjustable wash, heated seat, air drying, automatic lid and flush
Our verdict“I recommend the Vela Plus for buyers who actively want integrated bidet and automation features and can plan around its weight, fit, and power requirements.”
How We Picked
I built this ranking around the decisions that most often separate Signature Hardware toilet options: room fit, bowl comfort, cleaning access, installation demands, water use, and added functions. A round bowl can free up usable space in a compact bathroom, while an elongated bowl favors sitting comfort. The rough-in measurement gets particular attention because a mismatch can rule out an otherwise appealing model before finish or features matter.
I also weighed what the design changes for daily ownership. A skirted base hides the trapway and makes the surrounding floor easier to reach, but it does not remove the lifting and assembly demands of a heavy two-piece fixture. Chair-height construction can help some users sit and stand more comfortably, though accessible installation depends on the bathroom setup and the applicable guidelines. For the smart toilet, I treated the bidet and automation package as useful only for buyers who want those functions and can accommodate the unit’s installation requirements.
The order reflects usefulness for a defined buyer, not a claim that one design suits every bathroom. The Carraway leads for its combination of chair-height elongated seating and concealed trapway. The Benbrook with chrome follows as the strongest all-around skirted two-piece pick, with the brushed-nickel version serving buyers who need its stated ADA compliance and prefer that finish. The Bradenton earns a space-saving role, while the Vela Plus is a specialized feature-rich choice rather than the simplest replacement. Product information supplied for this comparison does not establish details such as flush performance testing, electrical requirements, or exact bowl height for every model, so I call out where buyers should confirm specifications before purchase.
| signaturehardware toilet | Configuration | Bowl | Material |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signature Hardware Carraway Tw | Two-piece skirted toilet | Elongated, chair-height | Porcelain |
| Signature Hardware Benbrook Tw | Two-piece | Elongated, skirted | Vitreous china |
| Signature Hardware Benbrook Tw | Two-piece | Elongated, skirted | Vitreous china |
| Signature Hardware Bradenton T | Two-piece | Round | Vitreous china |
| Signature Hardware Vela Plus O | One-piece, tankless | Elongated | Vitreous china |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Signaturehardware Toilets
I would start with the bathroom’s measurements, then decide which comfort and cleaning features justify a narrower set of choices. These five Signature Hardware models vary enough in rough-in, bowl shape, and function that a feature preference should not override fit.
Match the rough-in before choosing a style
Measure from the finished wall behind the toilet to the center of the floor drain bolts, following the measurement method in the installation instructions. The Bradenton specifies a 14-inch rough-in, while the Vela Plus specifies 12 inches. The other supplied listings do not state a rough-in, so check the complete manufacturer specifications before ordering those models. A toilet with the wrong rough-in can complicate or prevent a clean replacement, even if its appearance and features are right.
Also check side clearance, door swing, and the space in front of the bowl. Compare the toilet’s full projection and installed dimensions with the room, not just the bowl shape. The Vela Plus lists dimensions of 26.88 inches deep, 15.75 inches wide, and 18.5 inches high; use the manufacturer’s dimensional drawing to confirm which reference points apply.
Choose round or elongated based on use and clearance
Round bowls can help in compact bathrooms by reducing the front-to-back reach of the bowl, which is why the Bradenton has a clear role in this group. Elongated bowls, found on both Benbrooks, the Carraway, and the Vela Plus, provide more sitting room for many users. The tradeoff is a longer front profile, which may crowd a narrow room. I would measure actual floor clearance and prioritize the people who use the bathroom most rather than choose a shape from a product photo.
Decide whether a skirted base is worth the tradeoff
The Benbrook and Carraway are skirted, which conceals more of the trapway and makes the floor beside the toilet easier to reach during cleaning. That is a practical distinction from an exposed-profile design, but it does not mean installation is lighter or faster. The listed weights for these models range from 122.4 to 129 pounds, and both are two-piece toilets. A skirted exterior may also make access to certain plumbing areas less direct, so follow the manufacturer’s installation and service guidance.
Compare seat height and accessibility claims carefully
The Carraway is described as chair-height and meeting ADA requirements when installed according to guidelines; the brushed-nickel Benbrook listing also identifies it as ADA compliant. Those descriptions are useful starting points, not substitutes for checking installed seat height, clear floor space, grab-bar placement, and approach routes. The optional Carraway bidet seat adds one inch to bowl height, which can change the final fit. The Vela Plus lists a 15.75-inch bowl height, so buyers comparing accessibility should confirm comparable seat-height measurements for each option.
Balance water use against feature complexity
The conventional models in this roundup list 1.28 GPF; the Vela Plus lists 1.0 GPF. Lower flush volume is a meaningful specification, but the supplied details do not provide comparative performance testing, so I would not infer flushing strength from gallons per flush alone. The Vela Plus pairs lower stated water use with bidet washing, heating, drying, automatic functions, and other electronics. Those features can add comfort for a buyer who will use them, while a buyer seeking a simple toilet may prefer the easier-to-understand conventional choices.
Plan installation, included parts, and finish coordination
All five are floor-mounted, but the Vela Plus is one-piece and tankless while the other listed models are two-piece. Weight makes handling a concern across the range, especially for the 170-pound Vela Plus; arrange suitable help and confirm installer requirements. The Benbrooks include elongated plastic seats, and the Carraway includes a plastic seat. The Bradenton’s supplied details do not confirm a seat, so verify the package contents. Finally, choose the Benbrook lever finish to match existing chrome or brushed-nickel fixtures only after fit and bowl needs are settled.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Signature Hardware toilet in this comparison is best for a small bathroom?
I would start with the Bradenton if the room needs a round bowl to preserve front clearance. Its 14-inch rough-in is a firm fit check, so it only makes sense when that measurement matches or an installer confirms a workable plan. If the bathroom has room for an elongated bowl, the Benbrook or Carraway may offer more sitting space, but compare their full dimensions before choosing.
What is the difference between the two Benbrook toilets?
The two Benbrook listings share the two-piece skirted elongated design, 1.28 GPF rate, included elongated plastic seat, and 25-year limited warranty. The chrome-lever model weighs 122.4 pounds, while the brushed-nickel version weighs 122.8 pounds and is listed as ADA compliant. I would choose mainly by lever finish and the relevance of the ADA designation, then verify installation dimensions for the exact model.
Is a skirted toilet easier to clean?
A skirted profile can make the floor around the toilet easier to reach because it conceals the exposed contours of the trapway. The Benbrook and Carraway both use this design. It does not mean every part of the toilet is easier to service, and the ceramic fixture can still be heavy to handle; follow the manufacturer’s guidance for installation and maintenance access.
Which model has the most features?
The Vela Plus has the broadest feature package, including an integrated bidet seat with adjustable wash settings, heated seating, air drying, a night light, deodorizer, UV sterilization, automatic lid, and automatic or manual flushing. Those functions make it a more specialized choice than the conventional toilets here. Confirm the 12-inch rough-in, electrical requirements, installation instructions, and available service support before selecting it.
How should I choose between 1.28 GPF and 1.0 GPF?
The Benbrook, Bradenton, and Carraway list 1.28 GPF, while the Vela Plus lists 1.0 GPF. The lower figure indicates less water per flush as specified, but the supplied information does not provide comparative flush-performance testing. I would weigh that figure alongside the exact rough-in, bowl shape, desired functions, and manufacturer’s performance details rather than treat it as the only deciding factor.
Conclusion
For most buyers who want a straightforward upgrade, I would choose the Carraway when chair-height seating, an elongated bowl, and a concealed trapway are the priorities. Choose the Benbrook with chrome lever for a balanced skirted design and stated 25-year limited warranty, or its brushed-nickel counterpart when that finish and its ADA listing better fit the project. The Bradenton is the space-conscious pick only when a round bowl and 14-inch rough-in suit the room. I would reserve the Vela Plus for buyers who genuinely want integrated bidet and automatic features and can plan for its weight, 12-inch rough-in, and power needs. Before ordering any model, I would confirm rough-in, clearances, seat height, package contents, and installation requirements against the bathroom and the manufacturer’s current documentation.
Cold & flu season Picks
humidifiers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
